My Football Writer

Norwich City

news… comment… analysis

  • Home|
  • About|
  • #NCFC|
  • The Columnists|
  • Advertise|
  • Contact|
  • 19 June 2013

Wins or pure entertainment… while the debate has raged, the current style is surely a means to a prosperous Premier League future

Thu 14 Feb 13 by Gary Gowers

Since the Fulham game – not one for the purist for those who have erased it from the memory – debate has raged over whether the majority go to Carrow Road to be entertained or to see City win.

The obvious answer is both. In a perfect world we’d turn up once a fortnight – every week for the travelling Yellow Army – and watch the boys in yellow sweep aside all before them by playing ‘Barcelona’ football.

In truth – while the Catalan analogy is pushing it a bit far – we were given a taster of this strange phenomenon during the Lambert years. Granted, it is a little easier to achieve when faced with the likes Leeds, Peterborough, Millwall and Ipswich (just random examples), but wins were part of our staple and were invariably achieved with a bit of a swagger.

Now that we’re squaring up to the big boys the swagger has been replaced by a bit of a limp or maybe a stumble. Either way you get my gist… as we’re all now all too aware the football is no longer of the gung-ho variety but instead more pragmatic in nature.

In fairness to Chris Hughton – who has taken more than his fair share of brickbats since the weekend – last season was not without disappoints and frustrations, but amid the heartache and acrimony that accompanied those fraught few weeks in May, most were forgotten. Typically, when hearts get broken the wronged party can only recall the good times. That was us…

If my memory serves me correctly, one of the many statistical reports produced at the end of last season deduced that City played more long balls than anyone else. While I can recall being more than a little sceptical of its accuracy – how could City have hit more long balls than Stoke for example? – for this purpose at least, it doesn’t portray a team with a penchant for the beautiful game.

Yes, we played some decent stuff at times, but Barcelona (or even Swanseaola) we were not. But even on those bad days the moans and groans failed to reach the crescendo levels of this term.

So why is this season so different?

Whether we like it or not the spectre of Lambert still hovers ominously over Carrow Road. Every match, every passage of play and nigh on every pass is compared to how differently it would have been achieved under him. However hard we try (this piece being a classic example I guess) we all seem incapable of moving on, even although we constantly remind ourselves that he is the past and Hughton is the future.

And therein lies part of the problem.

A nicer, more honest, more genuine guy than Hughton you’re unlikely to meet. The courteous way he comes across is in stark contrast to some of the prickly operators we’ve had of late – and yes, that includes you know who – but still there remains this underlying feeling that he’s yet to be accepted into the hearts of the Canary nation.

While we can be a feisty old bunch at times, we do judge our own far more gently than those we perceive as ‘outsiders’. Those who have embedded themselves in the Norwich way – Darren Huckerby being a classic example – have always been afforded that little more slack. While he had the small advantage of being a fantastic player, Hucks too had his off days but they were invariably, and quite rightly, overlooked.

Unfortunately for Hughton – and through no fault of his own – he is still some way from being granted any kind of leeway and so finds his every move, every decision scrutinised to ridiculous levels..

All of which leads me back to my original question which – via a few cul-de-sacs – is do we expect Hughton’s City to entertain us or just simply win?

That the fare currently on offer is on the dour side is not in doubt – I defy anyone to say they enjoyed their last Saturday afternoon – but is it simply a means to an end?  If City manage to survive in this league, which – as many have pointed out – is still far from a formality, there are riches on offer beyond our wildest dreams. Given that giant pot of money should enable us to purchase some ‘quality’ – I’m thinking players blessed with the creativity gene – then the thought of a few more turgid afternoons between now and May is just about bearable.

If the current genre of football is Hughton’s vision of the future then perhaps it would be the time to make our feelings known. For now I’m happy to accept that he is using the current group in its most efficient and effective way with the end goal of Premier League survival. If that means not being entertained for the next few games, then so be it.

Having said all of that, with Norwich City firmly engrained in our DNA, there’s little doubt that going forward we would all accept a less-than-beautiful brand of football if it meant winning games. As much as we’d all love to see an expansive, free-flowing brand – who wouldn’t – I guarantee we’d find something to like, and defend, if we were winning more than we were losing. The majority of us will make the fortnightly pilgrimage to Carrow Road whatever the circumstances.

Typically, when having this conversation, you can’t ignore our friends from the Potteries who successfully ply their trade in top half of the league to full-houses. While Stoke fans probably, deep down, would prefer Pulis to provide them with a more attractive brand, while they retain their current status I suspect there are few complaints.

So while football is not a fully-paid up member of the entertainment industry – some prefer it described as a culture – we do go along in the hope of being entertained. Whether that buzz comes from an attractive display of passing football or a thumping win courtesy of some route-one stuff the end result for me is pretty much the same… a walk back across Carrow Bridge with a spring in my step and loads to dissect.

Let’s all just hope and pray that if, over the next couple of months, City are able to grind out two or three ugly wins then the end result will be a prosperous and exciting future… in the top tier.

If West Brom and Swansea can do it…

Posted in Column, Gary Gowers |

3 Responses to “Wins or pure entertainment… while the debate has raged, the current style is surely a means to a prosperous Premier League future”

  1. Douglas Millar says:
    February 14, 2013 at 9:33 am

    The problem with our current formation is that the way NCFC achieve defensive stability is to play two defensive midfielders. This makes it difficult to attack in numbers to feed on the crosses from the wingers and overlapping full backs.

    I remember the frailty of David Fox as a defender exemplified by him getting the first PL booking of last season and failure to track first Scholes then Giggs in Man U’s win at Carrow Road last season. Also Jonny Howson has also failed to keep close to his opponents near our penalty are -remember Dembele’s goal for Tottenham. So it seems that Johnson and Tettey must play to keep us in games.

    The challenge for the manager is how to mount an attacking threat with only four offensive players. Pilkington, Snodgrass and Hoolahan have all played well at times but with Holt often isolated and out of luck we don’t score many. Without Bassong’s and Martin’s goals where would we be!

    Perhaps the best solution -and one not favoured by the Manager – is to make a more attacking substitution after an hour giving our sub a real chance to affect the game.

    Chris Hughton has done well so far – you only have to see the success of some of his signings (Bassong’s, Garrido, Tettey and Snodgrass) but this will count for nothing if we don’t garner another 10 or 11 points.

    Let us hope that the training in Abu Dhabi will bear fruit and those points arrive sooner rather than later.

  2. Chris W says:
    February 14, 2013 at 10:54 am

    I think we have all come to accept that the “Back 6″ we currently play is here to stay! Liverpool (twice) apart we have looked solid at the back with the extra cover that Tettey & Johnson provide. So as Douglas says, the trick is getting more out of the “attacking 4″ and for an example we could maybe look at how United played last night. They too had a “back 6″ with Carrick & Jones playing as the extra 2, principaly to cover Ronaldo. But rather than completing the formation with 3 attacking midfielders and a lone (isolated) striker, they played 3 “out and out” strikers (in Rooney, Wellbeck & RVP) along with a single midfielder. Wouldn’t it be great to see Wes play behind a more advanced Snoddy (on his natural left!!!), Kamara (on the right) and Becchio/Holt acting as a more “joined up” attacking unit? Just a thought.

  3. James says:
    February 15, 2013 at 12:38 pm

    Just flicked over to the Pinkun website to see that we are only one of three teams to have not been awarded a penalty this season. To be fair, I can’t think of many instances where we deserved one and didn’t get it either (i’m sure there’s the odd one, but still).

    If you think about what the majority of penalties are give for, this is quite telling:
    - running at defenders who miss-time tackles
    - shots inside the box that are handled by defenders
    - keepers bringing down advancing forwards in one-on-one situations

    We have rarely been in these situations, so are unlikely to get penalties.

    What we have done is won a lot of free kicks in the area 20-30 metres within the edge of the penalty box – and thank God we have because Snodgrass in particular has been good at scoring these directly or delivering set free kicks that others (notably Bassong) has got on the end of. Worryingly for the goals-scored column, the effectiveness of Snodgrass’s free kicks has diminished of late.

    Attacking-wise I think we all acknowledge that we are not exactly multi-dimensional.

The Columnists

  • As the fixtures loom, long gone are the days of City entering a Premier League season with a sense of fear
    Tue 18 Jun 13 | 1 comment
    More from James Kent
  • For those awaiting the ‘white smoke’ of a new City signing, the new fixture list offers a brief distraction
    Mon 17 Jun 13 | 3 comments
    More from Gary Gowers
  • Kernow Canaries fly the yellow and green flag in a distant outpost, far removed from the Canary nation
    Sun 16 Jun 13 | 6 comments
    More from Chris Young
  • Rumours abound but the McNally powder remains dry as Toivonen and others keep their options open
    Fri 14 Jun 13 | 11 comments
    More from Gary Gowers
  • Lightning in a Jar – Part II. Those moments that have sent the Yellow Army to Canary heaven
    Thu 13 Jun 13 | 6 comments
    More from Edward Couzens-Lake

Latest Stories

  • City legends and celebrities alike descend on Carrow Road next Tuesday; all in the name of Jamie
    Sat 25 May 13 |
    More from Gary Gowers
  • Hughton looks to a busy summer and a fresh start with new faces as City sign off the season in typical Canary style…
    Sun 19 May 13 | 3 comments
    More from Rick Waghorn
  • The Canaries end the toughest of seasons in style as Man City suffer the rarity of defeat at the Etihad
    Sun 19 May 13 | 1 comment
    More from Gary Gowers
  • Thirty years after City’s last triumph in the FA Youth Cup, Neil Adams and his Under-18s do the same again
    Tue 14 May 13 | 3 comments
    More from Gary Gowers
  • City finally deliver the goods when it really matters – a 4-0 win to secure a £60 million prize and a place in the Premier League next season
    Sun 12 May 13 | 4 comments
    More from Rick Waghorn
  • Home|
  • RSS|
  • Contact|

© Copyright Rick Waghorn 2013 | All rights reserved | Not to be reproduced without prior permission

Disclaimer: The information on this website consists of personal opinions. Whilst we have taken all reasonable steps to ensure that the information contained on these Web pages is accurate and correct at the time of writing we do not accept any liability whatsover for any loss or damage caused by reliance on this information.

We do not accept any responsibility for information contained in other websites to which this site links. We strongly advise users to check any information before acting or relying on it.