• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

My Football Writer

My Football Writer Norwich City news… comment… analysis

Norwich City – news, comment and analysis

Find the best betting sites
  • Home
  • About us
  • The Team
  • Archives Index
  • Patreon
  • ADVERTISE
  • Contact us

If the rumour mill is to be believed, Robbie Keane could be a short-term fix in our quest for more firepower

21st November 2012 By Edward Couzens-Lake 5 Comments

Please share

On August 9th 1997 we welcomed in the new season with a game against Wolves at Carrow Road.

Those who attended will remember the match-winning performance of a 17-year-old Wolves debutant. He ran the show, winning plaudits in abundance for his all-round display and the goals he scored in their 2-0 victory.

His name? Robbie Keane.

Now, a little over 15 years later, the name Robbie Keane is doing the rounds at Carrow Road again. For, despite the very obvious distraction of Manchester United as league opposition, word got around last Saturday that Keane has been identified as a possible loan signing for the club.

The reaction to this possibility – at best – was remarkable. It wasn’t a time to be seen sitting on the fence. Opinion was divided – it was either a massive thumbs up and resounding “Yes!” – or an equally strident and disbelieving “No!”. The joy of football: polarising issues like little else. But who is right? And are these short term deals even worth considering in the first place?

One view is that this short termism policy, in football, is often a necessary evil. Logic dictates that long term planning and investment is key, whether this relates to club infrastructure or the playing squad. And that is absolutely right. “Young and hungry” has been the mantra attached to would-be Norwich players over the last few years for that very reason.

Yes, the initial outlay may well be a costly one. However, the intention would be that the club’s investment in them would pay off in their improvement as a player, their ‘subscribing’ to the Norwich City ideal, growing with the club, and, if the inevitable happened, rewarding the clubs initial risk by having a very high resale value.

It is how Norwich City have always operated; we’ve done it before; we’ll doubtless do it again.

Short termism goes against this perceived best practice. We’ve seen it fail before. Myriad players arriving at the club on a temporary basis throughout a season (15 players joined Norwich on loan throughout the 2008/09 campaign). No heart, no commitment, no connection with the club. Players just going through the motions.

A disinterested mix of ingredients resulting in a recipe for footballing disaster.

Do we want to walk that road again, do we want to take on a costly player whose best years are behind him and whose motives are nothing more than a wish to stay match-fit during the US close season?

I still say yes. If the possibility exists to get Keane on loan, let’s do it.

I hear the words of protest. I’ve pretty much outlined the base of any argument against signing Keane above. The logic is hard and unrelenting. He’s too old. Too expensive. His legs have gone. Uncommitted. An indulgence. Plan for the future; that means getting in our own players, those who want to play for us. Invest long term. Tangible, not intangible.

I hear it all. But I maintain that we should look to secure Keane’s signature – if the possibility is there.

Because at the present time, right now, short termism is important. Nothing is more important to the club and supporters than staying in the Premier League this season. The financial rewards of doing so are obvious and tempting.

Every point counts, every clean sheet, every goal scored. Nothing is as important as NOW.

And, right now, if we can get someone in who can hit the ground running and be part of that now-forget the next month, next year, next season – then we need to welcome them with open arms.

Keane’s qualities are obvious. He knows the Premier League, he knows how the game is played at this level, he knows the teams and the players he would be playing against. And he knows where the goal is.

The likes of, for example, Charlie Austin, do not. He’s never played in the Premier League, he doesn’t know the teams or players he’d be up against and is completely and utterly unproven at this level. Indeed, he’s only had a few months experience at Championship level. Is that worth upwards of £6 million? No.

Last season people were saying we should sign Jay Rodriguez. We didn’t – but Southampton did. His form this season to date? Ten league appearances, one league goal. One? In exchange for £7 million? OK, so he’s an investment, a footballing slow burner. But we need goals now and in the Premier League, not next season back in the Championship.

Do you think Robbie Keane might have yielded a better return, given ten first team appearances for Southampton this season? I do as well.

As for those who claim he is too old? Grant Holt is just nine months younger than Keane – is anyone going to face up to Holty and tell him his legs have gone? It’s all a moot point, of course.

The prospect of Keane coming here may be entirely academic and there have never been any plans to sign him.

But what if he did? What if he was to sign, to play eight games for us and score four, maybe five goals in that time? Just enough goals and influence to secure us 10-12 points, points that might make all the difference come May.

Might that then be the best bit of ‘short termism’ the club has ever got involved with?

And he is absolutely, definitely, without a shadow of a doubt capable of doing just that.

Would you say the same about Charlie Austin?


Please share

Filed Under: Column, Ed Couzens-Lake

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Toad says

    21st November 2012 at 3:29 pm

    I agree. We need all the goals we can get and he knows how to do that. It seems a bit silly not to take him short term, even if he gets 2 or 3 they will be important goals. If he’s not doing the job, he won’t play…can’t hurt.

    Reply
  2. Yellows! says

    21st November 2012 at 4:41 pm

    Good point, well made. Sounds like just the kind of signing we need in January!

    Reply
  3. Mike K says

    21st November 2012 at 4:47 pm

    No way Ed’, it aint gonna happen. Bookmark this post 😉

    Reply
  4. Brusilov says

    21st November 2012 at 10:23 pm

    I’d take Charlie Austin over Robbie Kean any day personally but in truth I can’t see us getting either player.

    Reply
  5. Bucks Canary says

    22nd November 2012 at 10:26 am

    Two points to consider. Firstly, the disruption to a newly settled team and squad – we’re playing well: bringing in a short term outsider, with no connection to the club may well put some noses out of joint and end up being counter-productive. Secondly – I just don’t think he’s got it any more. I can’t remember the last time I saw him have a good game. So, on balance, no.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

FIND MY FOOTBALL WRITER ON

As featured on NewsNow: Norwich City news” style=

Norwich City News 24/7

#NCFC LATEST

c11shy James Cushing @c11shy ·
13m

#ncfc take the fun out of quite a lot really

Reply on Twitter 1619090214718423040 Retweet on Twitter 1619090214718423040 Like on Twitter 1619090214718423040 Twitter 1619090214718423040
thekitmanuk TheKitman.co.uk @thekitmanuk ·
21m

2010-11 Norwich City Home Shirt (M)

🛒 Shop Now - https://www.thekitman.co.uk/product/2010-11-norwich-city-home-shirt-m/

#NorwichCity #NCFC

Reply on Twitter 1619088192678031360 Retweet on Twitter 1619088192678031360 Like on Twitter 1619088192678031360 Twitter 1619088192678031360
nairncounty Nairn County FC @nairncounty ·
23m

✍️We are delighted to have completed the loan signing of Nairn-based midfielder, Kenny MacInnes from @ElginCityFC 🥳 More details here 👇

https://nairncountyfc.co.uk/news/kenny-macinnes-joins-on-loan/

#ncfc #nairncounty #ItsaNairnThing

Reply on Twitter 1619087932693876738 Retweet on Twitter 1619087932693876738 2 Like on Twitter 1619087932693876738 8 Twitter 1619087932693876738
ian_m1 Ian 🔰 @ian_m1 ·
23m

What this doesn't show is the moment the Sutton keeper (Roffey?) went over and shook Flecky's hand after he completed his hat trick. The spirit of the game and the former magic of the Cup encapsulated. #ncfc

Reply on Twitter 1619087838049636352 Retweet on Twitter 1619087838049636352 Like on Twitter 1619087838049636352 1 Twitter 1619087838049636352
fan_banter Fan Banter @fan_banter ·
33m

Fans hit out at the FA for handing out ban to Wigan player over flare 'incident' - https://fanbanter.co.uk/fans-hit-out-at-the-fa-for-handing-out-ban-to-wigan-player-over-flare-incident/

#watfordfc #ncfc #twitterclarets #safc #rufc #wafc #bcfc #rovers #utmp #bristolcity #ccfc #pusb #htafc #hcafc #coyh #boro #millwall #qpr #readingfc #twitterblades #scfc

Reply on Twitter 1619085338059612169 Retweet on Twitter 1619085338059612169 Like on Twitter 1619085338059612169 Twitter 1619085338059612169
Load More...

Copyright © 2023 21VC Ltd | All rights reserved | Not to be reproduced without prior permission.

Disclaimer: The information on this website consists of personal opinions. Whilst we have taken all reasonable steps to ensure that the information contained on these Web pages is accurate and correct at the time of writing we do not accept any liability whatsover for any loss or damage caused by reliance on this information.

We do not accept any responsibility for information contained in other websites to which this site links. We strongly advise users to check any information before acting or relying on it.

Developed and Hosted by