This is probably a daft question; easily answered.
But does anyone actually enjoy supporting their favourite English Premier League football team? Like really enjoy.
Enjoyment was obviously easy when it was everyone’s favourite League One and Championship football team; and there was the enjoyment that comes with the novelty of a first season back in the top flight.
And, of course, there are 45 minutes like those on Saturday when the footballing fates suddenly decide to smile; when – backs firmly pressed against the wall – character on and off the pitch rises to the fore.
But it strikes me that life in the English Premier League for clubs of a certain, middle rank is as much a test of endurance as anything.
No-one enjoys being anywhere near that bottom three, but the reality is that if you have a run of games against the top seven, you will be there or thereabouts – just as much as if you have a run of games against the lesser lights, then you can ‘enjoy’ the brief respite that being 12th or 14th brings.
Enjoying a good cup run – as Norwich have this season, albeit by their lowly standards – lasts as long as the cup draw allows. Be thrown in against a United 2nd XI then delivers a long and expensive night out in Manchester.
With, in City’s case, the prospect of a return visit and a repeat experience looming large.
That the Canary faithful travel in such great numbers and in such voice is a huge testament to their own, deep-seated sense of loyalty – one that is bound ever more to a real feeling of being duty-bound to sing myself hoarse at grounds six-hours hence.
It also crosses my mind that the bond between local players and local supporters is also something of a previous age; I doubt this crop of players are as open and available for simple conversations as the team that had a Crook, a Goss or a Gunn at its heart.
Maybe conversation comes through different mediums – Elliott Bennett knows how to turn his Twitter following to charitable advantage. Perhaps that is where the ‘bond’ now lies?
But it is something that I find myself returning to all too often; that what, actually, has the Premier League to offer the long-suffering supporter of a Norwich or a West Brom, a Stoke or a Villa?
However much Paul Lambert might have sprinkled his magic dust over the Canaries in that extraordinary spell at the helm, I don’t get any sense of Villa doing much more than being another team in the mid-table mix. I have no feeling for them being the new Everton.
I guess if you asked the nearest Southampton fan, they would say that they are having the time of their recent lives; they, too, have plumbed some serious depths. But can now look down on neighbours Portsmouth with a sense of smug satisfaction. It may be a while before those two cross paths again in the league.
And yet such South Coast derbies were ‘the games I always looked forward to… The games that I used to really enjoy…’
Such is the warped nature of English football’s finances that it sends one into (brief) delirium, the other towards oblivion.
The media, too, will play a part.
Find yourself anywhere near the bottom three and everyone reaches for a new dictionary – club in crisis, on the brink, staring down the barrel, facing the abyss. None of which are designed to improve the punter’s mood as they head for another fraught afternoon being put through the emotional mill.
Perhaps that is where the enjoyment does come in; the Fer-inspired highs after the Morrison-fed lows.
But it is certainly not a relaxing way to spend any Saturday afternoon; free from the stresses and strains of the working week…
Maybe, as a society, we have come to thrive on high drama; roller-coaster rides that swing between abject despair and total delight are what we find ‘enjoyment’ in.
I’m probably getting old. Although I’ve always been one for something of a quieter life.
But, for me, enjoying a simple game of football is – or was – one of life’s more simple pleasures.
Now the whole experience of being a supporter seems altogether more complex. Let alone more expensive – which in turn can only feed my level of frustration if I sense I am not getting full value for my hard-earned money.
And I will vent such anger across a whole new raft of platforms and audiences; seven days a week.
To yearn for the simple days of the Championship is probably the wrong way to think, but I’d make a small wager with you that for many a seasoned City punter one of the most enjoyable seasons in recent memory would be that one in the third tier of English football and not the first.
Being in the top tier of the greatest professional football league in the world is all too much like hard work.
I see what point you’re trying to make, but it’s lost at the most basic level. It’s not a case of either struggle in the prem, or sit back and enjoy winning at a level below. Those years between the mid 90s and eventual relegation to league 1, apart from 2002 to 2004, did not deliver a relaxing Saturday afternoon, free from the stresses and strains of the week…
Good article, Rick. I must admit that in 30 years of following City I’ve never felt so uninspired and lackluster about going to watch us play. As much as I’ve blamed the current management team for that, it’s as much to do with the context you describe as anything else. I do enjoy a game of Connect 4 on my iphone if things get particularly boring though, so modern life isn’t completely rubbish.
I tell everyone that will listen that one of my favourite seasons of supporting Norwich was in the third tier of English football. I could get tickets to matches, easily and cheaply! The opposing fans were all friendly. We had real heroes again. We won games!
However, let’s not forget the eras of John Bond, Dave Stringer and Ken Brown. They were great times too.
There is a ray of hope. After 9 games we are top of the Fair Play league (even despite the Cardiff debacle which must have cost us a few “respect for opponent” points).
Win that and if England gets one of the 3 extra places awarded we could be in the Europa Cup First Qualifying Round with all the possibilities that offers up.
Matt(2) – wow, you really know how to let your hair down!
It is a grind down the wrong end of the league (half-time on Saturday particularly so) but that makes a win all the sweeter.
Swansea fans were on cloud 9 last season but I suspect are suffering anxiety this one. Southampton fans – enjoy it because it won’t last.
I’d be more than happy to be sat mid-table with a comfortable view up and down.
Such is the plight of all of us – to suffer the slings and arrows etc. I think it is especially so as the years advance along with the waistline.
I think I am just addicted. Having put up with 55 years of the ups and downs ,I am not giving up now.
I think the Lambert years have been my favourite with lots of ups but during his time I saw the canaries 6 times ( I live far away now)and never saw them win.So this year I decided that Aston Villa was one game to get to as he would not win with me there and looked what happened.
We are not a club who can buy league titles and we will struggle at times but there are a lot of positives. We are debt free, our youth system is to be admired, we have McNally to name a few.
In my case it is City till I die.
Sorry, Rick – I disagree with almost every word. Fans of 70 clubs would read this and shake their heads in disbelief: how ungrateful can we be? The Premiership is great, even for a not-top-six club, and watching the calibre of players now wearing the yellow-and-green is fantastic.
Moreover, I don’t buy the ‘carefree League One days’ line. I was just as stressed about our staying at the top of that league as I am about staying in the Prem. The rollercoaster of emotions during Southend (h) was pretty indistinguishable from what we went through at Carrow Road on Saturday evening.
Stress comes with supporting your team – it’s always there. But wouldn’t we rather have our stresses than Ipswich’s? OTBC
My matchdays are more about anxiety than enjoyment, but that’s more to do with not being able to attend as many games as I’d like than anything else. League 1 was good, the Charlton game an obvious highlight, but the resentment of being in that division in the first place prevents it from being great. My most enjoyable times were with the original Walker teams, Worthington’s championship & Lamberts last promotion. The achievement of getting back to the Premier was immense, to say we don’t want to be there would make it pointless. Regarding the current team, I’d far rather watch them than what we had in the Grant & Roeder seasons.
I have to disagree. If you follow football, surely you follow your own club and the top division in your country; who wouldn’t want to follow those two things at the same time? Even if your club is at the wrong end of it most of the time, to be rubbing shoulders with the best in the land. As long as you’re in that division there’s always a chance that surviving a bad year could be followed by a successful season, where you beat some of the big boys and prove people wrong – see 92/93.