That was a hard one to take. Another one.
But this time the players left the Carrow Road pitch to thunderous applause. A standing ovation even in the face of defeat. And that, on this occasion, said more than the heart-wrenching scoreline.
The statisticians tell us City are doomed – as do the bookies and the pundits – and it’s impossible to argue with a form guide that shows five straight defeats and seven on the bounce away from Carrow Road.
By the time Norwich kick-off at Old Trafford on Saturday teatime they will have been marooned on 32 points for over a month. Inertia at a time when momentum is king.
Chuck into the mix the final three fixtures and perhaps if I were Paddy Power I’d be arriving at a similar conclusion.
But I don’t think we’re done. Not by a long shot.
It’s impossible of course to ignore the defensive soft centre that still exists, and there is much for Neil Adams and his team to pore over from yesterday’s opening twenty minutes, but equally there is plenty to build on from the final seventy.
And similarly there was plenty to admire from the technical area.
It was clear from said opening period that the plan wasn’t working. The formation that was ‘almost but not quite’ at Craven Cottage was horribly pulled apart and Adams acted. The shape of the midfield was changed and with Leroy Fer operating from a more central position so was the balance of the game.
Ultimately those opening exchanges were to prove costly and City were effectively blown away in that fraught opening (and we’re not the first team to have suffered similarly at the hands of the ‘mighty reds’) but the response was emphatic.
I was advised on Saturday (from a Southampton supporting colleague of all people…) that we were going to be on the wrong end of a 6-0, and I can’t pretend that it didn’t flick through my mind at 2-0 down after 11 minutes, but I needn’t have worried.
Instead, rather than being steam-rollered, the Canaries rolled up their metaphorical sleeves up and dug in. The heads stayed high and the chests remained puffed out. And what we witnessed was a City side ‘giving it a go’. Something we have been asking for all season.
And Brendan Rodgers’ men knew they had been in a game. The sight of them holding the ball in the corner to wind down the clock was in itself a concession that they had been in one; not something that has been required in recent Liverpool/City encounters.
That City managed to find the net twice against the champions elect and take them to the wire suggests progress, but with just three games remaining the big question is can they turn promise into points, or is it too little too late.
None of us know the answer of course but there is a verve and a purpose about our play right now that suggests there is still life. The players appear to believe it. So should we.
There were stirring performances aplenty yesterday, but Robert Snodgrass again took the honours with another display that blew holes in the theory that it matters more to the supporters than it does to the players.
A friend and I were discussing pre-match how – barring a few notable exceptions – it is nigh on impossible for the players to feel what we’re feeling. After all, they are just custodians of the shirt who are ‘passing through’. Few have experienced the ups and downs of the yellow and green that we have and few have felt the pain we have. Their’s has more to do with dented professional pride
But judging by the reaction upon the final blast of Andre Marriner’s whistle it genuinely does matter. Snodgrass was out on his feet, having given every last ounce of energy to the cause; Nathan Redmond again appeared close to tears; Bradley Johnson and Russell Martin, both suffering from similar levels of desperation.
And of all of them, it was Johnson I felt most sorry for yesterday. While the quality of his passing has been called into question many times, none of us have ever doubted his willingness to fight and battle.
Yesterday – with one painful exception – he produced a performance that married the two together perfectly. Alas it will be the intercepted pass to Martin Olsson for which his afternoon will be remembered; his desperately unlucky deflection over a stranded John Ruddy merely rubbing salt into the wound. Which is a shame.
He, along with Snodgrass and Howson (there is a theme developing…) typified the hunger for the battle that is going to be so important over the next three games.
The trick for Adams – one which so eluded Chris Hughton – is of course to translate good Carrow Road performances, which are buoyed by a raucous Carrow Road crowd, into winning performances on the road. That will be the real test.
Amidst the hundreds of permutations I still remain hopeful that a point from either Manchester United or Chelsea and a win on the last day against Arsenal will still be enough for safety. There are plenty out there who will tell us otherwise, and the media-love for yesterday’s opponents is something we can only dream of, so perhaps a siege mentality is what’s needed to see us limp over the line.
To rely on favours from others will undoubtedly end in disappointment. We need to do it ourselves – the hard way.
And after yesterday I still believe we can.
I’m with you Gary in believing we might just scrape it, although my point route is a win at Old Trafford (not before time) and maybe a point off Arsenal – although they worryingly dispatched a usually gritty Hull side, and their 4th place battle is likely to go to the last day.
Bradley S. and the other ex-Leeds boys have taken flack through the season but they stood out yesterday in the fightback which raised everyone’s hopes.
We do need other results to go our way and the Sunderland vs Cardiff game next Sun. is likely to be a 6 pointer with knobs on.
For me yesterday`s performance was most disappointing as it showed us all what might have been with a tactically astute manager capable of motivating the squad. Such a shame McNally failed to act quickly enough.
In truth I think Adams got it tactically wrong yesterday, and it ultimately cost us the game. To play the diamond against them was asking for trouble. In fairness, he acted quickly to rectify it, but it was too late.
Re 2: I don’t see how you can accuse Hughton of a lack of tactical astuteness – question his ‘philosophy’ and approach but he is a damned experienced football man (player, coach and manager) who took us to 11th in the PL. His time had run out as it does for all managers these days (except Wenger/SAF).
Would we have battled back yesterday under him? probably not, but would we have been 2-0 down in 10 minutes? Probably not.
Adams is a managerial novice by any definition – he made mistakes but is learning on the job. The players have responded to a new face/voice as often happens (for a honeymoon period at least) after a change.
I think Adams’ dilemma is “who do I play up front” as it has to be recognised that we don’t have a striker who is firing on all cylinders and have not had all season.
The answer is crucial to our hopes of survival as I’m convinced we will carve out chances-we just need them converted.
Available candidates:
Elmander
RVW
Hooper
Becchio
Morris
I think we have to play Hooper in the remaining away games and if we still have no more points,go for broke with Elmander and RVW in the last game.We know both of these players can ,and have, done it at the highest level and I’m a great believer that class “will out”-hopefully in that game!
Played with the sort of verve and intensity we haven’t seen since Lambert’s time.
@Jarrolder
I think there’s no question who you put up front. Hooper has scored 8 goals (all competitions) this season, despite a period out injured, and playing second fiddle to RVW whenever Ricky was fit.
Overlooking Hooper was one of Hughton’s biggest mistakes. I truly believe he could have scored another 5-10 and put us well towards safety, had he been started instead of RVW.
@Arnold
Not to harp on about CH. But he was hired as someone who was meant to have the tactical ability to make us defensively strong. He was only partially successful at that and failed in all other areas.
Inevitably time does run out for a manager at a club, but the good ones crop back up somewhere.
Right now Adams may have lost two matches, but I can’t help but believe the way our club is performing is doing nothing but wonders for his reputation. Hopefully he keeps it up, regardless of the league we’re in.
Dave B. – re:cropping back up – don’t write CH off so quickly. I’m pretty sure he’ll be back in a decent job next season..possibly Lambert’s replacement at Villa Park!
I’m backing Adams all the way for the next 3 games but is he the man to lead us in the long term? I don’t think so – I suspect most Swansea and Spurs fans would like an experienced man to take over from their current ‘interimers’. I hear Moyes might be looking for employment in the summer!