Neil Adams has already has some big calls to make in his ten games at the City helm. In the fruitless five he had not only the unenviable task of finding a formula to oversee one of the great escapes but also had a couple of contentious disciplinary issues to manage.
That he made a decent fist of the latter played a big part in him being handed the gig full-time. In hindsight the former was the most toxic of poisoned chalices.
But the landscape has shifted significantly since Adams sat, looking very small and – dare I say – a little out of his depth, in those luxuriant red leather Old Trafford pitchside seats. If, unlikely as it seems, he were to lead his troops back to the self-titled Theatre of Dreams (nightmares Louis?) any time soon we’d see a very different demeanour.
In the same way the City boss is slowly (and quite rightly) morphing from media man to tight-lipped manager with regard to dealings with said media, he is also growing in stature in the dugout. Yes, he may still forget the occasional handshake and still has to refine his technique when it comes to berating the fourth official Fergie-style but for the stuff that really matters he’s learning quickly.
The style of City’s play has been much discussed and Adams has stayed true to his and David McNally’s pledge of attacking football but, just as important, has been the decisive and measured decision-making. Whereas one of the big failings of the last regime was its inability to recognise and redress setbacks, Team Adams has already show a willingness and ability to do just that.
It’s still early days of course – and mistakes will be made along the way – but the signs are good.
And at the end of this week, as we emerge the most tiresome of international breaks, Adams has another conundrum on the horizon: who should start against Cardiff City?
A little obvious of course – that’s what he’s paid for – but assuming those who arrive back in the Fine City after heading to the four corners do so with all limbs intact City have, by my reckoning, 22 outfield players vying for those ten starting shirts.
Naturally, in true footballing tradition, those currently in situ are more than likely to retain the jersey – and nothing happened against Bournemouth to warrant wholesale changes – but Adams is not short of options.
The only positions where there is just an either/or choice is at full-back – a straight shoot-out between Russell Martin and Steven Whittaker on the right and Martin Olsson and Javier Garrido on the left.
Assuming Martin and Olsson (yes, I know…) arrive back unscathed they will get the nod.
It’s when we consider the centre-back options it gets really interesting.
Michael Turner will be a shoe-in – he’s been magnificent of late and is probably the first name on the team-sheet right now – but I confess to having no idea who his partner will be in the Cardiff City Stadium. So much so I’m even unable to trot out the old ‘smart money’ cliche.
With Ryan Bennett unfortunately out of action for several weeks, it looks to be one from three in a frame containing Carlos Cuellar, Jos Hooiveld and Ignasi Miquel. Cuellar’s outing against Crawley suggested he’s still short of match fitness – as one would expect with him having been a free agent – but one suspects Hooiveld and Miquel will both have had a full pre-season.
Whether that gives them both the edge over the ex-Sunderland man only time will tell, but there will be some eagle-eyes at work over the fields of Colney this week – and by next Saturday there are going to be some disappointed new boys.
Given the form of Alex Tettey and Bradley Johnson it’s hard to see either missing out on Saturday but waiting in the wings are a plethora – all of whom can add something different to the midfield mix.
Gary O’Neil, judging by an impressive couple of cameos, is itching to be afforded a chance to shine and has already shown himself to be sharp in the tackle and measured in possession. He’s certainly one who can ‘do a job’ and provides Adams with an ideal option when a cool, calm head is required.
Vadis Odidja-Ofoe has clearly been bought to fill the void left by Leroy Fer and, if YouTube is to be believed, is of a similar mould. He looks to be a box-to-box type with an eye for goal and will not have made a move to the Championship on the premise of being on the City bench. Alex and Brad – you’ve been warned.
Jonny Howson’s pre-season injury was ill-timed and from being a near-certain starter he now finds himself down the pecking order. But the ex-Leeds man’s quality – which will shine in the second tier – will see him quickly force his way into Adams’ thoughts once he has returned to match fitness. He just needs time.
Fortunately, with the aforementioned alternatives at Adams’ disposal, for once that is something he can be afforded and there is currently no necessity to rush him back, as has been the case in the past.
In terms of the attacking third, there are options apenty. Wes Hoolahan has played himself into the starting XI and remains pivotal to all that is good about City, and he too will currently be one of the first names on the team-sheet.
To date Kyle Lafferty and Nathan Redmond have been Adams’ preferred choice of ‘wing-men’ and both have done enough for that to stay the same.
Lafferty has surprised many, not least because of his comfort in playing out wide rather than down the middle (as his height would suggest) and also because of a workrate – which is right up there with that of Johnson’s. But he needs a goal. He was drafted in as part of the solution to the goalscoring problems and, while his record suggests he’s not going to be prolific, he needs to chip in occasionally.
But he’s a character and has already gone a log way to win over the faithful. For those with a Twitter tendency, his banter (am I still allowed to say that?) with Ryan Bennett on deadline day – where they discussed the whereabouts of Gary Hooper – was very amusing.
Redmond – fresh from some time away with the Under-21s – will hopefully return reinvigorated and will certainly benefit from an away day. And with the will he/won’t he riddle now resolved thanks to Jim White shutting that bloody window, perhaps he’ll also benefit from some certainty over his future – for the short-term at least.
Assuming he returns to Norfolk injury-free I expect him, along with Lafferty, to start next Saturday.
It goes without saying that the lone striker role picks itself. Lewis Grabban’s five goals in five Championship games tells us all we need to know and has already set the bar high for those who fancy a shot at leading the line.
Cameron Jerome, Gary Hooper – once he regains fitness – and Jamar Loza are in the chasing pack right now, and while all will no doubt feature as the season progresses, at the moment the jersey is Grabban’s to lose.
So, while Adams may have a conundrum of the good kind moving forward, the team for Cardiff – having gone through the options – almost picks itself doesn’t it? The big dilemma appears to be who to play alongside Turner – and if that’s the manager’s most pressing problem then things must be ticking along nicely.
Now lets’s just get this international lark out of the way and get back to something we care about.
“On the Ball City…”
Sadly Russ Martin looks to be having problems with a Groin strain while away, Stachan is giving him time to be ready for their big game with Germany.
Hopefully he won’t be risked, he would be missed but we have cover now hope there is no more bad news
I hope Vadis will replace Johnson. We need more running power, more penetration, from midfield Johnson has played fairly well so far (I was in the stands in both games he scored), but I will not jump on the “praise Bradders” bandwagon just yet. For me he is too limited.
Cardiff is a team playing a lot of short passes through midfield, and we need energy there. Vadis could do a job if fit, and it is maybe good for him to make his debut away from home. I will expect, though, Adams to start with Tettey/Johnson and Vadis to come on as a sub.
Lafferty out wide does not work for me. I know we don’t have too many who can play left wing without being too predictable (Redmond will cut in 98 of 100 times playing on the left), but something needs to be done there, I think. Not drastic, of course, but Lafferty is not effective out on the left.
Thankfully, with the new centrebacks in the house, Martin will be moved out to the right back. Martin is for me no centreback. Lacks height and muscle to perform well there. For me, Martin lacks the pace to play fightback too, so it is a tossup between Whitts and Martin for the RB spot.
Leftback I suspect will be Garrido, as Olsson have been out a long time now with suspensions, family issues, etc. Garrido is nowhere good enough, as he lets in far too many crosses, and is way short of match practice after a season on the sidelines. I hope Olsson starts, even without any games under his belt for over a month.
Also expect Adams to be content with a point at Cardiff. On paper it is OK with a draw at Cardiff, and most fans will be happy with it before the game, me included.
nicely presented, Gary – not much to pick holes in 🙂 . I can’t agree with grefstad on Cardiff, though! We battered them home and away last year and should have easily won 6 points instead of 1. They’re a basket case of a club at present and are there to be rolled over by a confident Norwich side. OTBC!
The amazing thing, as Gary says, is that we now have some 22 genuine contenders for the 10 outfield spots. Don’t think that was ever true in our three Premiership years. Certainly credit to Neil Adams’ growth that he’s prepared to give himself the challenge of managing all the expectations.
Much as I love Wes when he’s on song, I’m not as sure as Gary that he’s a shoo-in (think that may be the spelling) to the team. He wasn’t effective against Bournemouth, and surely Vadis will be an option sooner rather than later. As City showed towards the end of the B’mouth game, 4-4-2 is an option they’ve been working on; Vadis and Tettey might be a powerful combo in that formation.
Though it’s frustrating to have international absentees, Neil has actually had most of his squad in training, particularly the new intake. So he’ll have had a chance to look at their fitness, demeanour etc – it’ll be very interesting to see his selection for Cardiff.
Point taken re Wes, Stew (4) and, on reflection, was a tad presumptuous. Although he has been a regular starter so far, as the season unfolds – and with such an array at his disposal, those dancing feet may be used more sparingly – probably on a ‘horses for courses’ basis.
Either way, I can seldom recall a squad of such depth.
No pressure Neyul! 😉
Bringing in three centre backs – Cuellar, Hooiveld, and Miquel seems a tad like overkill and not knowing who will prove to be a long term starter. Cuellar was a liability for both Villa and Sunderland against Norwich in the Prem. Let us hope Neil Adams will know by next week whom he thinks will be the best bet.
Also the team needs Howson back as soon as he is fully fit. He is the only midfield player apart from Wes whose first movement is forward. Johnson and Tettey tend to slow down moves which allows opposing defences to get set.
Now he is with City for the foreseeable future, Hooper needs to get playing as soon as possible. He is a goal scorer. Lafferty is not. Get him fit and starting asap!