After consecutive 0-0 draws, in which City did well to get nil, yesterday’s five goal extravaganza was a bolt right out of the blue (as it were).
Another event-less 0-0, which many were predicting, would have been a step too far on what was possibly the bleakest, coldest Carrow Road experience I can remember, but luckily for everyone it was arguably the most enjoyable 90+ minutes of the season at home.
Typically, City made heavy weather of getting over the line but get over the line they did and on this occasion, there was more than just the brilliance of Angus Gunn and James Maddison for us blogger-types to mull over.
In fact, get this, there were several positives… some of them unexpected.
Key to making what was a slightly surreal afternoon an enjoyable one was that Reading came to play. They may be struggling and they may be hovering fairly close to the unmentionable zone but they did arrive with an intention of getting the ball down and passing it.
And with Jaap Stam’s men playing in a similar style to City, the faithful were spared the ‘get-in-their-faces’ approach that has all too often ended in an attritional Carrow Road stalemate. Add to that the relatively high defensive line deployed by the visitors and it made for the rarity of an open, end-to-end encounter.
An early goal helped too, and Mario Vrancic’s stooping far-post header from Grant Hanley’s flick-on set the tone; the Bosnian benefitting hugely from the boost of that goal for the rest of the afternoon.
What followed was actually pretty decent, and there’s no question the dual threat of a firing Josh Murphy and an ever-improving Onel Hernandez adds excitement to a formula that has all too often been low-key and dull. One wonders if indeed it is the presence of the all-action Cuban that has driven Josh to rediscover that ability of knocking it past his fullback and getting to the byline.
Whatever the reason, that Josh can now be seen knocking that ball into the grass behind his opponent, dropping his shoulder and then gliding past has to be a good thing – and was something badly missing in his mid-season slump.
The frustrations around his low-quality final ball, on occasions, and his tendency to get brushed aside a little too easily amidst the hurly-burly are not unreasonable but he’s no longer a ‘promising youngster’ and it could just be that these weaknesses in his game that will keep him at Norwich City rather than see him soar to the heights of Jacob.
Maybe it’s a trade-off – his searing pace and ability to leave opponents for dead versus the aforementioned downside – and one that we’ll have to live with while working on those areas of improvement. But for an hour yesterday, I thought he was very good.
Hernandez has added something new to the mix, and not just the fact we have finally have ourselves one of those stocky, low-centre-of-gravity types who is hellishly hard to knock off the ball. He’s clearly quick and strong but also has that ability to get supporters on the edge of their seats when faced one-on-one with his fullback. He’s exciting.
And in terms of his work rate and defensive diligence, it’s easy to see why Daniel Farke trusts Hernandez to do a job for the team; the very antithesis, in fact, of how Spurs loanee, Marcus Edwards is perceived by the head coach, even though his appearance on the bench yesterday did at least confirm that he exists.
The Cuban too suffers from that winger’s affliction of an inconsistent final ball but. again, if he had that last piece of the jigsaw perfected he’d probably have his sights set higher than a mid-table club in the second tier.
Hernandez’s high-energy style makes it tough to go the full 90+ at full throttle so there will be spells in games where he drifts out – it’s inevitable – but that he had the energy and intelligence to make the run that led to the cross that led to Maddison being up-ended for the pen was good to watch.
Dennis Sbreny, along with Hernandez, also enjoyed his most fruitful shift in the yellow and green, and there were signs that if we afford him the time to develop there is a good ‘number 9’ in there. Alas, when his big moment arrived he chocked – snatching at his golden chance to score midway through the second-half – but there was enough in his all-around game to suggest he has the capability to be the player we want him to be.
His first touch was pretty good, he held it up quite well and was able to bring others into the game; all components that go to make up a successful lone striker. The missing, rather important, element of scoring goals will hopefully come, and he’s definitely one who will benefit from a full Farke pre-season.
Ironically, the debate over the Maddison/Leitner short corner routines that caused such angst in the last two home games was rendered largely futile yesterday, with the first two goals coming directly from Maddison corners. I was in the ‘the chances of scoring from a corner are so slim, take a short one’ camp, which shows precisely how much I know.
Finally, couldn’t end without returning to Vrancic’s contribution. For one who was vilified over the first few months of the season – justifiably on occasions – he has slowly won over the doubters with some very accomplished, classy appearances. More often than not they have been cameos but yesterday he impacted on the game for the full 95, often through his quality range of passing but also for the ability to get a toe and nick back possession for City.
I was pilloried early in the season for using his “languid” style as mitigation for an apparent lack of appetite but I stand by it. His isn’t the all-action style of Hernandez or Harrison Reed – who was also excellent yesterday by the way – but in his understated, cultured way he has adapted his game to the unsophisticated ways of the Championships.
To say that Alex Tettey, Tom Trybull and Moritz Leitner were not missed yesterday is probably the best compliment we can give Messrs Vrancic and Reed. It won’t be a combo that works every game, but yesterday, in the frozen wastelands of NR1, it did.
So, a win, an enjoyable one, and let’s not use the fact that Reading were ordinary or City hit no great heights spoil the glow emitted by our first win in eight. We’ve bemoaned a lack of entertainment, let’s not twist the knife when there has actually been some.
No mention of the ref? How they finished with 11, I’ll never know.
Good point Dave…. but I do try as much as possible to fall into ‘the ref was crap’ trap. Even if he was.
The ref’s performance fell apart in the last 20 minutes – he’d been pretty good up until the 70 minute mark imo.
He missed so much late in the game it was unreal. Looks like we came through it unscathed though and with three points in the bag and a 13-day break to ease some lumps and bumps I’m not moaning to much. Unlike a certain Mr McCarthy of Ipswich fame…
An enjoyable game, despite the sub-zero temperatures and biting wind chill thrown into the mix.
The width and pace provided by both Murphy and Hernandez, with a few decent crosses into the box, gave City a refreshing attacking dimension – something that’s been lacking for much of the season.
Yes, Reading were poor in the first half, but they certainly showed up for the second and asked City’s back line a few questions.
The only downside as I left Carrow Road was that numb feeling caused by the win actually meaning so little – almost a worthless win!
Last paragraph Gaz …
Delighted with yesterday’s performance and three goals. Just still a bit concerned that all three from set pieces rather than open play where we need to convert opportunities. Pleased for Vrancic and Srbeny. Maybe a four at the back is better at home with two quick wingers. If so it would be Hanley and Zimmerman for me at centre back. All interesting and promising.
Fair points by all.
I’m trying not to prejudge who’ll come and go in the summer, having started last year with confidence that we’d keep Jonny Howson….
Much more pace in the team yesterday especially with Josh having a better game on the wide left and Onel Hernandez (“the Cuban Missile”) on the right!
Also Srebeny can mix it with the best of them and I like the way he looks for a n open space or takes up a good position in the box The goals will come!
At last some goals (and entertainment!!) to raise the spirits on a very cold afternoon.
Funny how the arrival of Hernandez, (who for 75 minutes was very good), has got Josh back on song, although as you say Gary, the final ball choice from both of them needs some work.
You don’t need me to tell you that generally Maddison has been excellent this season, but I have to admit to being more than a little surprised when he was (once again) given the man of the match award.
For once i thought that there were a few who were more deserving on the day.
O T B C
HI gary a great read
From reading some articles today on Newsnow the Football League world are saying the majority of city supporters want Farke out before the start of next season I just hope this proves completely wrong for two reasons
1) City don’t have the money to pay out karge compensation to Team Farke
2) Team Farke are finally getting to grips with this league
With the turnover of players city have had this season it is no wonder cities form has been erratic plus the injuries to key personnel from the start of the season.
The other bit of news that was very surprising from is that Football League world also reporting Huddesfield will match cities asking price for Maddison of £15million are they for real.
So now we are on level points with IpsWitch down the road lets get everyone fit for the final thrust and leave them in our wake or is it their wake
I have no direct (or indeed indirect) line to the Board but I feel it’s fairly safe to say Daniel Farke will still be in charge of our squad next season.
I really don’t believe hardly any of us (apart from the odd fruitbat on Twitter or wherever ) wants him out!
To be honest Alex, I find these articles absolutely pointless. However, this poll (of only about 150 ‘fans’) is about whether they think Farke will take us into the top 6 next season, which is different to whether they want him out. I’m a fan of Farke, but I’m not sure I would vote yes to him taking us to the top 6 next season. I can’t think of anyone I’d prefer to have in charge though