• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

My Football Writer

My Football Writer Norwich City news… comment… analysis

Norwich City – news, comment and analysis

Find the best betting sites
  • Home
  • About us
  • The Team
  • Archives Index
  • Patreon
  • ADVERTISE
  • Contact us
Once labelled a ‘Wes-hater’, but really? He’s in my all-time City XI… is he in yours?

Once labelled a ‘Wes-hater’, but really? He’s in my all-time City XI… is he in yours?

27th April 2018 By Craig Bailey 14 Comments

Please share

Legend is a term that gets bandied around all too frequently these days. Wes Hoolahan, however, deserves that label and more in a Norwich City context.

A few years back I casually wrote a tweet saying I thought Wes was our most overrated player of all time. I have also written a joke tweet wondering whether he had an inner ear infection due to the number of times he spins in a circle.

I have even stated that all of our managers have dropped Wes at different points while in the Premier League (note: I didn’t say I agreed with that) and have dared to criticise him when at times he (1) slowed the game down too much, (2) beat a man for the third time with strikers waiting or (3) gave the ball away on the halfway line.

I was also guilty of suggesting his goal tally isn’t as good as it should be for a player of his talent and I’ve also been known to be critical of him during the Hughton era and the potential move to Villa. I was at Villa Park when he didn’t celebrate scoring and the “s**thouse of a club” comment annoyed me, but I understood it was born of frustration at not playing.

I should have known better. The backlash of those jumping to conclusions and filling in the gaps allowed by a limited character format whilst wearing their Westacles was swift and harsh, but not necessarily just.

I was labelled a Wes-hater! Back in the real world, nothing could be further from the truth.

I love Wes. He’s given us some truly magical moments on the pitch, moments no other player I’ve seen since I started watching in City in 1985 could do.

Wes is hands down the best attacking-midfielder I have seen play in yellow and green.

When I said he was our most overrated player of all time, I certainly did not mean he was a bad player, far from it, he’s obviously not. That tweet came off the back of being involved in a conversation where fellow City fans claimed that Wes was better than Ozil, Silva and Bale based on some half-baked unsubstantiated stats.

I found this totally ludicrous and tweeted as a result. I was also quite drunk.

I also believe no player should be beyond criticism, so have pointed out the flaws as well as the magic. As one of my friends once stated when I asked how we’d played today, “We were OK, Wes was Wes, awful one minute and absolutely brilliant the next!”.

Wes has had tremendous support from the crowd, as he stated in his open letter; when he makes mistakes the crowd accepts it, whereas the same mistake by Nathan Redmond or Josh Murphy will be met with a series of groans around the ground.

This is not Wes’s fault, of course, and maybe his magic gives him that grace. I would say, however, that Carrow Road would be a much better place for everybody if all players were treated similarly to Wes, especially younger developing players. Food for thought.

The end of an era when a successful manager like Paul Lambert or player such as Hoolahan moves on gets you thinking. I’ve lost count of the number of times I’ve thought ‘wow’ while watching Wes play.

It got me thinking: why have managers dropped him in the Premier League? And why hasn’t he played for his country more often?

The sad reality of that is that neither City or RoI have been considered good enough in their respective environment to play a CAM regularly. He’s been deemed a luxury player. And that probably has something to do with his pace and physical stature.

Personally, I think that’s a crying shame and a missed opportunity for both. With the benefit of hindsight, I would much rather have seen the team built around Wes and as we went down anyway a few times, do it in a way that was enjoyable.

I remember him having a cracking game with Gary Hooper against Man Utd under Chris Hughton, only to get dropped in the next game.

So while I understand the dilemma, if you play a CAM you can be less structured and organised, whereas if you play players like Wes anywhere else – for example on the left wing of a 4-4-2 – you lose your shape when he goes wandering. But being blunt, I don’t care!

I’d rather have players like Wes on the pitch than not. I admire defensive organisation and structure, but it’s not exciting at all. Life’s too short, play creative players and ride the roller coaster!

Alas, there is no point lamenting the past. What I’d like to focus on is the joy in being able to witness the best attacking-midfielder this club has ever had. It is sad, but also inevitable.

Sure he had faults, but don’t we all? I, for one, am glad he did, as without faults he would be up there with Ozil, Silva and Bale and dare I say it even Messi, and we certainly would not have seen him play for a decade at Carrow Road.

It’s a shame that we could not have found a player-coaching role for Wes given that players like James Maddison have stated they have learned a lot from him. But given our financial state there’s sadly little room for sentiment.

This also got me thinking of my best ever City squad and thought it would be fun to share. The rules are you have to have seen them play yourself and the formation/players must work in the real world so to speak. It’s really difficult and I’ve changed my mind even from my tweet the other day on the same subject, but here goes:

Woods

Culverhouse, Bruce, Watson, Bowen

Crook, Goss

Huckerby, Hoolahan, Eadie

Sutton

Subs: Gunn (Bryan), Drury, Fleming, Maddison, Bellamy, Fox, Holt

I can pay Wes no higher compliment than including him in my best ever City XI and when you consider players like Roberts, Robins, Ekoku, Phillips, Sherwood, Townsend, Green, Channon, Barham and more haven’t even made the list it shows how tough it is!

So, in summary, I’d like to say thanks Wes, I’ve loved watching you play football and will miss your moment of genius; my personal favourite being when you put half of the Rotherham defence on their backsides before calming stroking it home.

Good luck with whatever you’re moving on to and I hope to see you back here one day.


Please share

Filed Under: Column, Craig Bailey

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Andy Delf says

    27th April 2018 at 9:03 pm

    Sorry Wes you’ve been great but didn’t quite make it into my first team.

    Keelan
    Culver house
    Bruce
    Mackay
    Bowen
    Peters
    Martin O Neil
    Huckerby
    Eadie
    Holt
    Reeves

    Subs
    Woods
    Hoolahan
    Stringer
    Bellamy
    Drury
    Madison
    Forbes

    2
    Reply
    • Gary Gowers says

      28th April 2018 at 6:25 am

      I’ll see you Delfie… and raise you….

      (4-5-1)
      Keelan;
      Culverhouse
      Bruce
      Butterworth
      Bowen;
      Huckerby
      Crook
      Peters
      Hoolahan
      Bellamy;
      Sutton

      Subs:
      Gunn (B)
      Watson
      Suggett
      Eadie
      Gordon
      Reeves
      Holt

      1
      Reply
  2. martin penney says

    28th April 2018 at 7:22 am

    Here comes an old-fashioned 4-4-2 from me:

    Keelan

    Culverhouse Bruce Newsome Bowen

    Gordon Crook Townsend Huckerby

    Sutton Fleck

    Subs:
    Woods
    Drury
    Watson
    Peters
    Fox
    Holt
    McDougal

    1
    Reply
    • Craig Bailey says

      28th April 2018 at 8:28 am

      Loved Newsome! And how could I not find room for Flecky!

      1
      Reply
  3. JohnF says

    28th April 2018 at 8:35 am

    Surprised nobody picked Ron Davies, the best player to play for Norwich. Check his record.
    4-4-2
    Keelan
    Culverhouse
    Bruce
    Sutton
    Bowen
    Peters
    Martin O’Neil
    Eadie
    Fox
    Bellamy
    Davies

    Subs:
    Maddison
    Watson
    Huckerby
    Holt
    Boyer
    Stringer
    Hoolahan

    Reply
    • Craig Bailey says

      28th April 2018 at 10:46 am

      I never got to see Ron play, so breached my rules!

      Reply
  4. Andy Delf says

    28th April 2018 at 9:18 am

    Poor old Iwan was a giant of a man and epitomised all that I love about Norwich and I still couldn’t find a spot for him. What a great article and responses. More of this please. JohnF I missed out on seeing Ron Davies but he also sounds like the type of striker I would have enjoyed.

    3
    Reply
    • JohnF says

      28th April 2018 at 9:46 am

      Mat Busby described him as the best centre forward in Europe.
      Topped the top division scorers two years running playing for Southampton.
      Second one shared with George Best.

      Reply
  5. Chris says

    28th April 2018 at 9:30 am

    Impossible task! I can’t get beyond Keelan or Woods.

    1
    Reply
  6. martin penney says

    28th April 2018 at 9:32 am

    I really should have found room on my bench for Phil Boyer – McDougall used to thrive off him.

    I couldn’t consider Ron Davies as I never physically saw him play for us.

    1
    Reply
  7. John Holland says

    28th April 2018 at 10:09 am

    My team based on watching since 1970:

    Woods, Culverhouse, Bowen, Bruce, Watson, Crook, Gordon, Phelan, Bellamy, McDougall, Sutton

    Subs Keelan, Newsome, Martin R, Howson, Huckerby, Boyer, Peters

    Not sure I have the balance entirely right though

    Reply
  8. Max says

    28th April 2018 at 12:28 pm

    4-4-2
    Keelan,
    Culverhouse,
    Bruce,
    Watson,
    Bowen,
    Suggett,
    Townsend,
    Peters,
    Eadie,
    MacDougall,
    Davies

    Subs: Woods, Drury, Forbes, Hoolahan, Huckerby, Bellamy, Ashton

    1
    Reply
  9. Martin says

    29th April 2018 at 7:53 am

    Gunn (Bryan)
    Nedergaard Fleming Newsome Bowen

    Crook Goss

    Eadie Hoolahan Huckerby

    Holt

    Green
    Drury
    Maddison
    Holt (gary)
    Bellamy
    Robins
    Roberts

    Pretty similar – but as I read your team I just couldn’t disagree with the vast majority!
    Never got to see Sutton/Fox play live as first attended game was in 94/95 season, otherwise theyd have been included. I also went for a ridiculous bench just for fun!

    Reply
  10. Tony says

    29th April 2018 at 8:34 am

    Keelan,Culverhouse,
    Forbes,Stringer,
    Bowen.
    Barham,Phelan.
    Goss,Townsend.
    Eadie,Sutton.
    4_5_1.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

FIND MY FOOTBALL WRITER ON

As featured on NewsNow: Norwich City news” style=

Norwich City News 24/7

@NorwichCityMFW latest

Tweets by @NorwichCityMFW

#NCFC LATEST

chrisbart0n 🔰Chris Barton🐤 @chrisbart0n ·
57m

What was with all of the singing in the South stand last night!? 🤣🔰 #singupthesouthstand #NCFC

Reply on Twitter 1557278995279929347 Retweet on Twitter 1557278995279929347 Like on Twitter 1557278995279929347 1 Twitter 1557278995279929347
bevdogg_ncfc Bev Dog 🔰 @bevdogg_ncfc ·
57m

I know it’s early, but does anyone want some chips?
#ncfc

Reply on Twitter 1557278885422800898 Retweet on Twitter 1557278885422800898 Like on Twitter 1557278885422800898 Twitter 1557278885422800898
pobfarmer Paul Farmer @pobfarmer ·
59m

If that had been a volley it would of been almost a carbon copy of the Tettey master piece #ncfc

Reply on Twitter 1557278558925606913 Retweet on Twitter 1557278558925606913 Like on Twitter 1557278558925606913 Twitter 1557278558925606913
canarycitizens Canary Citizens @canarycitizens ·
1h

Highlights: Norwich City 2-2 Birmingham City. #NCFC

https://youtu.be/Y7U8hbENffk

Reply on Twitter 1557277561511727109 Retweet on Twitter 1557277561511727109 Like on Twitter 1557277561511727109 Twitter 1557277561511727109
saund65 Canaries Caption It @saund65 ·
1h

Don't think even the most optimistic of #NCFC fans would have had a Chilean midfielder scoring a Panenka penalty on their August bingo card.

Reply on Twitter 1557276188162539520 Retweet on Twitter 1557276188162539520 Like on Twitter 1557276188162539520 2 Twitter 1557276188162539520
Load More...

Copyright © 2022 21VC Ltd | All rights reserved | Not to be reproduced without prior permission.

Disclaimer: The information on this website consists of personal opinions. Whilst we have taken all reasonable steps to ensure that the information contained on these Web pages is accurate and correct at the time of writing we do not accept any liability whatsover for any loss or damage caused by reliance on this information.

We do not accept any responsibility for information contained in other websites to which this site links. We strongly advise users to check any information before acting or relying on it.

Developed and Hosted by