• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

My Football Writer

My Football Writer Norwich City news… comment… analysis

Norwich City – news, comment and analysis

Find the best betting sites
  • Home
  • About us
  • The Team
  • Archives Index
  • Patreon
  • ADVERTISE
  • Contact us
TV WEEK: Star trekking across the Universe with Picard and our Ed…

TV WEEK: Star trekking across the Universe with Picard and our Ed…

6th June 2019 By Edward Couzens-Lake 8 Comments

Please share

My name is Ed. And I’m a Trekker.

I will, at this point, distinguish between a Trekker, such as myself and a Trekkie.

Trekkie’s are devotees of the original Star Trek series, as conceived and written by Gene Roddenberry and made by NBC.

And I can take it or leave it.

Trekkers, on the other hand, are fans of the more recent adaptations of the franchise, that is, anything and everything from Star Trek: The Next Generation up to, and including the not very imaginatively titled Star Trek: Picard which is due to be screened on Amazon Prime towards the end of the year.

We’re all, to be perfectly honest with you, getting rather excited about the return of Jean Luc. It’s been thirty or so years since his scrap with the Romulans, as depicted in Star Trek: Nemesis (it is believed that the humble colon would have become extinct had it not been rescued by the writers of these particular TV series and films) and he has, in that time, been assumed retired from Star Fleet and is spending his time managing the family vineyards in France.

Except of course, something is stirring in the galaxies nether regions and Picard is needed again.

I’d tell you more but, a), you probably don’t want to know and, b) that’s just about all I and everyone else knows about it at the moment.

Agog with excitement? You’d better believe it.

Most people associate Star Trek with Roddenberry, who saw it as a type of ‘wagon train to the stars’. Westerns were big business on US television in the 1960s and Roddenberry thought, not unreasonably, that the concept would transfer well from a wagon train to a starship.

The endless journey and all the discoveries and privations it would bring. Good guys and bad guys. Exploration. Drama. Love.

But no conflict. Because Roddenberry had postulated that, by the time the 23rd century had dawned, mankind would have got over its petty squabbling and war-like behaviour and that everyone would get along very nicely indeed.

No wars. No politics. No money. Just a permanent state of bliss.

Which is admirable. And something to be unequivocally wished for.

But in terms of television, it turned out to be hugely boring when it came to storylines.

The elephant in the room in fact. Except, of course, with this being Star Trek, the elephant would be a man in a rubber suit that had a hose attached to it in order to pass off the appearance of a trunk.

Many of the original series’ writers presented some brilliant scripts to Rodenberry, which he rejected out of hand if they even as much as hinted at someone not getting along with someone else on the Enterprise.

Wall to wall magnolia which, fortunately, a few of the show’s clever writers (before they were fired) managed to circumvent in their scripts by introducing numerous alien species who provided some much-needed antagonism.

Unfortunately for Roddenberry and NBC, the sixties and early seventies were a time when science fiction, as a genre, started to become just a little bit grittier and darker.

Gone was the derring-do of Flash Gordon and Buck Rogers. To be replaced by storylines where things went wrong and, more often than not, had gone wrong because mankind had erred in some fashion.

The Day the Earth Caught Fire (seriously, if you have not seen this film, do so – it’s on YouTube), 2001, The Andromeda Strain and, memorably at this time of green awareness, Silent Running.

No-one wants to watch an hour and a half of Utopia. Audiences back then, as they do today, want dark storylines, suspense, disaster, death and the apocalypse.

Witness, for example, the success of Chernobyl right now.

If it was a programme about everyday adventures at a wind farm, adventures that were brutally interrupted one day when the wind dropped for an hour or so, then no-one would bother to watch it.

But a nuclear reactor blowing up? Bring it on.

Back in the early 1990s, the writers who had been involved in the Star Trek franchise were aware that Roddenberry’s influence on his creation was waning.

Which meant it wouldn’t be long before the Chernobyl of the franchise came into glorious existence.

Star Trek: Deep Space Nine (DS9) is set on a space station. Which means rather than the characters portrayed in the previous programmes going out and discovering strange new worlds, the inhabitants of assorted strange new worlds come to them.

It’s a seven-season romp packed full of skulduggery, betrayal, war, corruption, politics and out and out hostility. Roddenberry would have hated it.

It’s a hugely underrated piece of television that is highlighted by great writing and superb character portrayal and development.

There are strong women. And weak men.

Roddenberry’s idea of anathema. He liked his women undressed and his men undressing them.

Which makes me think that he was, in truth, the best and the worse thing to ever happen to Star Trek.

Best because he thought it all up in the first place. And worst because he then made it a pretty insipid place to live and work in.

He wanted a universe that was perfect in every way. Perfect, that is, as long as that image of perfection tallied with his rather old-fashioned vision of what it might be.

The Universe of DS9 is anything but that.

It’s fractured, its dark, its full of tension and uncertainty.

Just like the world we live in today.

But it’s a Universe that makes for some wonderful entertainment and storytelling.

Which is more than enough for me in my downtime.

Because my name is Ed. And I’m a Trekker.


Please share

Filed Under: Column, Ed Couzens-Lake

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. martin penney says

    6th June 2019 at 9:23 am

    Hi Ed

    I really enjoyed reading that – and I can’t stand Star Trek in any incarnation:-)

    I’ve never seen any of the movies and certainly not a Star Wars film either, but your take on Roddenberry was fascinating.

    The only sci-fi I’ve ever enjoyed was the film 2001 – A Space Odyssey and the TV show The Outer Limits. However without Star Trek there would never have been Red Dwarf, so I respect it for that influence alone.

    A great article.

    1
    Reply
  2. Alex B says

    6th June 2019 at 10:43 am

    Hi Ed

    Jeffery Hunter who made his name in westerns was the first captain of the Enterprise as Captain Christopher Pike in the original pilot for the show but was dropped for the series and William Shatner wig as well got the job.

    DS9 and the next generation and enterprise are always good watching but I found it hard to get into Voyager it reminded me of lost in space on a bigger scale.

    Looking back to the late ’60s there were a few space progs that could have taken off and there are still rumours that Blake7 could be coming to the big screen as Tom Cruise has the rights to it.

    Would Roddenberry ever have approved of the films and as George Lucas said someone needed to update the westerns and Roddenberry was that man with Star Trek and he took it on with Star Wars and now JJ Abrahams with the rebooting has improved it again.

    It seems the western with their new frontiers can adapt into the 22nd century.

    1
    Reply
    • Ed CL says

      6th June 2019 at 6:32 pm

      I’d be very happy to see a reimagining of Blakes 7 -classic story line of good versus bad in a dystopic setting and some great scripts, even if the BBC didn’t spend much on the sets. Well worth a 21st century update.

      Roddenberry was a fascinating figure. Few people enjoyed working with him and even fewer seemed to like him. But they all wanted to be part of his vision albeit with a desire to change it.

      1
      Reply
    • Tim says

      7th June 2019 at 11:01 pm

      Tom C has the rights? Not sure how I feel about that if true. Sad news re Blake’s 7 this week in that Paul Darrow, Avon, died on Monday.

      Reply
  3. Stewart Lewis says

    6th June 2019 at 3:33 pm

    Great stuff, Ed.

    I’ve just learned a lot about Star Trek – not least an explanation for the more and less satisfying aspects of the franchise.

    1
    Reply
    • John Mitchell says

      7th June 2019 at 1:38 pm

      Blake’s 7 was wonderful TV at the time, probably my favourite non-sports programme as a teenager. Servalan was one of the great sci-fi villains (perhaps rivalled by Gul Dukat of DS9?). It was indeed far truer to human nature than Star Trek ToS ever was. B7 also had a great mix of good stories alongside longer term arcs, even if it did slightly lose its way towards the end. I’d rather remember B7 as it was, complete with overuse of quarry scenes, production that now looks distinctly low tech, and the deeply unsatisfactory ending. I’m not sure I’m that keen on the idea of a reboot; it’d have to be truly excellent, and as British as the original to win me round.

      Reply
  4. John says

    6th June 2019 at 6:58 pm

    I wonder if I’m missing something here, as I have never seen a single episode/film of Star Trek; StarWars, or Dr Who……
    They just don’t don’t interest me (or my other half) one little bit…..
    Not being a Sky/NetFlix (or anything other than Freeview subscriber) I might be missing something, but we get to see most eventually….Breaking Bad was brilliant, and (from further ago) the wonderful Fawlty Towers and Only Fools & Horses…Not sure if any of today’s comedies will be quite so everlasting, but Mum (on BBC2) is just superb!

    O T B C

    Reply
  5. David Bowers says

    6th June 2019 at 9:57 pm

    Part time Trekkie and I’ve never heard of the term Trekker. Sounds like Trekkies are equivalent to the Jewish religion, love all the old fire and brimstone and topless men in deserts. While Trekkers are New Testament loving Christians.

    I once saw Shatner’s one man show on Broadway and it was quite something.

    One minor note, Picard’s last rumble was with the Remans, not Romulans and of course, himself.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

FIND MY FOOTBALL WRITER ON

As featured on NewsNow: Norwich City news” style=

Norwich City News 24/7

@NorwichCityMFW latest

Tweets by @NorwichCityMFW

#NCFC LATEST

fan_banter Fan Banter @fan_banter ·
33m

Astonishing video shows steward take no shit fighting with Birmingham fan - https://fanbanter.co.uk/astonishing-video-shows-steward-take-no-shit-fighting-with-birmingham-fan/

#watfordfc #ncfc #twitterclarets #safc #rufc #wafc #bcfc #rovers #utmp #bristolcity #ccfc #pusb #htafc #hcafc #coyh #boro #millwall #qpr #readingfc #twitterblades #scfc #swans

Reply on Twitter 1560152012716531719 Retweet on Twitter 1560152012716531719 Like on Twitter 1560152012716531719 Twitter 1560152012716531719
thisismccann Michael McCann 🇺🇦 @thisismccann ·
37m

#NCFC are back in action tomorrow night with #Millwall in town - can the Canaries build on a first win of the season after seeing off Huddersfield in my midweek ⚽️📺🎙? You can still catch the best bits on @SkyFootball #Norwich #EFL #football

Reply on Twitter 1560151071103881217 Retweet on Twitter 1560151071103881217 Like on Twitter 1560151071103881217 Twitter 1560151071103881217
pinkun The Pink Un @pinkun ·
40m

🤔 Is now the time for Josh Sargent to kickstart his #NCFC career?

In his latest column, @chris_sutton73 explains why he believes the #USMNT forward took a step forward on Tuesday night👇🔰

https://app.pinkun.com/9216296/content.html

Reply on Twitter 1560150363931648000 Retweet on Twitter 1560150363931648000 Like on Twitter 1560150363931648000 1 Twitter 1560150363931648000
norwichcitylive Norwich City Live @norwichcitylive ·
1h

Dean Smith's verdict on 'underrated' #NCFC star after first win vs Huddersfield Town

https://www.norfolklive.co.uk/sport/football/football-news/dean-smith-underrated-norwich-huddersfield-7477276

Reply on Twitter 1560144464936546306 Retweet on Twitter 1560144464936546306 Like on Twitter 1560144464936546306 Twitter 1560144464936546306
radenjack4 RadenJack @radenjack4 ·
2h

Ghost Mug, Halloween Mug,̖ #Halloween #Coffee Mug, Ghost Coffee Mug, Gift For Here 🎇
#euronextparis #fundamentalanalysis #allthesours #s04e10 #siliconvalleyhbo #ncfc #costoflivingcrisis #puckfair22

https://www.etsy.com/listing/1282943713/ghost-mug-halloween-mug-halloween-coffee?t=1660799596

Reply on Twitter 1560132705878061057 Retweet on Twitter 1560132705878061057 Like on Twitter 1560132705878061057 Twitter 1560132705878061057
Load More...

Copyright © 2022 21VC Ltd | All rights reserved | Not to be reproduced without prior permission.

Disclaimer: The information on this website consists of personal opinions. Whilst we have taken all reasonable steps to ensure that the information contained on these Web pages is accurate and correct at the time of writing we do not accept any liability whatsover for any loss or damage caused by reliance on this information.

We do not accept any responsibility for information contained in other websites to which this site links. We strongly advise users to check any information before acting or relying on it.

Developed and Hosted by