A lot has changed since City last stepped onto a football pitch.
A new prime minister, a new monarch, a new investor. Yet some things remain the same, including the ability of the Championship to produce an absorbing, frenetic game. Short on quality, high on entertainment.
The City fans paid their tribute to the late Queen immaculately. A minute’s silence. A rousing rendition of God Save The King.
Both sides set their game plans out early. City looking energetic, trying to move the ball quickly through the thirds. Bristol pressing very high, with three at the back and using the five in midfield to create overloads in wide areas, particularly on their right.
Norwich looked a little ring rusty, with Sam Byram, Tim Krul, Marcelino Nuñez and Kenny McLean all giving the ball away cheaply at the back. In the Premier League, it would have been 0-4 but the Championship is more forgiving and the City defence was able to recover.
Something else that doesn’t change, despite the early season accusations of being past it from some followers, is the ability of Teemu Pukki to finish clinically.
Todd Cantwell was fouled deep in City territory, Kenny McLean played a swirling pass forward, and Kai Naismith misread it horribly. Pukki didn’t. The Finn flicked the ball upwards, away from keeper Bentley before heading into the empty net.
City continued to play some neat football without ever really threatening, while the Robins tried to stamp some authority on the game. Sykes on the right was seemingly the main outlet, giving Byram and McLean more than their fair share of work to do.
But with McLean helping out on the left, the City midfield was left short-handed and there was the ever-present threat of the ball being switched inside to take advantage of this.
The intensity of the game began to increase. A passage of three or four ‘robust’ challenges on the edge of the City penalty area got the crowd going and City breaking forward down the right with Josh Sargent.
His cross didn’t beat the first man but as Bristol City played it out from the back, the stretching McLean intercepted the ball, which fell kindly for Aaron Ramsey. The loanee played a delightful ball between the two Bristol centre-backs into the area in which Pukki thrives.
There was never any doubt that the Finn would make it 2-0 and, in doing so, he became the fifth-highest scorer of all time for City.
But the goal signalled a period of Bristol pressure that would be only broken by the half-time whistle. They pressed high, preventing City from getting out.
The only recourse was a long ball, and Pukki is never going to win those. Bizarrely Sargent, who was so effective playing as a lone Striker, was unable to compete for the ball when it came to him in a wide position in the air. The pressure built on City.
The Robins’ goal, when it came, started with the overload on the right. Atkinson, bursting forward from the back was always going to outmuscle Nuñez as he scythed through the middle of the park. He played it wide to Wells who crossed for Conway to head home, who had managed to get goal side of Hanley.
There were no changes at half-time, and the second half continued pretty much as the first had finished. City showing a little more threat going forward but producing few meaningful chances.
Dean Smith made changes on 57 minutes, with Todd Cantwell being replaced by Onel Hernandez. Cantwell had played well, but the extra pace was sorely needed.
The tactical switch forced Nigel Pearson to switch to a four at the back to counter the new threat. Smith also withdrew Ramsey for Gabi Sara. The loanee had looked decent enough on the ball but a little lightweight at times.
For the rest of the game, City seemed obsessed with punting the ball to Hernandez at the first opportunity. While it was sensible to use his pace and the space he had, a lot of the time a more measured move forward may have been better.
Nuñez nearly got the Cuban away twice; the first was offside, the second intercepted.
After 62 minutes, Nuñez made a great run out of defence, sliding past two or three midfielders before setting Pukki free on the left, who won a corner.
Sara stepped up to take it and delivered a perfect curling ball to the near post. Sargent hardly had to move before delivering a powerful header that beat both keeper and the player on the line to restore City’s two-goal advantage.
Bristol City weren’t done though. They continued to press forward, Pearson making a series of attacking subs.
They won two corners in quick succession, but City held firm albeit helped by Nakhi Wells hitting the side netting from the second.
Hernandez was seeing a lot of the ball but was at his most frustrating most of the time. His best moment came when he bullied his way past Weiner, cut inside and moved the ball infield. The ball came across to Max Aarons on the right. His cross was cleared down the line behind Aarons but Nunez made a great covering tackle.
Sara was making his mark on the game. A neat flick to Pukki, whose ball didn’t quite reach Hernandez, but City won the ball back again, ending in a rasping, dipping shot from Nunez being clawed behind for a corner.
From the corner, the ball fell to Pukki whose instinctive shot with the outside of the boot was somehow saved by Bentley.
On 74, Smith brought on Danil Sinani in place of Pukki, Sargent moving infield. The logic seemed clear – beef up the defensive effort on the right and add some muscle in the middle.
Minutes later, Nuñez was wide on the left. Without support, he did well to retain possession moving back towards his own goal.
When City cleared the ball came straight back at them. Aarons tangled with a Bristol attacker and was hauled down, taking a boot to the head as they fell. The ball fell kindly to Sinani who elected to play it infield towards the corner of the penalty area and Nunez. The little man was unaware of the on-rushing Williams who steals the ball for Semenyo to lash past Krul.
On 82, City had a chance to put the game to bed. Hernandez broke forward and played the ball across to Sinani in acres of space. His first touch wasn’t confident and unlike Pukki in the first half, it never felt like he would score. He didn’t.
A few minutes later, Smith made his final changes. Hanley looked to have been struggling with a shoulder injury and was replaced by Ben Gibson. Nunez was also replaced by Kieran Dowell.
If Mark Attanasio was watching the final few minutes of the game, his physician may be advising him to reconsider his stake in the club.
Bristol continued to attack, City tried to counter. When six minutes of added time were signalled, an audible groan sounded around Carrow Road. But City defended stoutly – Gibson taking the safe, no-nonsense approach on several occasions.
As the game drew to a close, Sara did very well on the right. His excellent ball found Sargent, accompanied by Hernandez, both through on goal. Referee David Webb hardly enhanced his already waning popularity in NR1 by blowing the final whistle.
Do, pick what you like out of that lot!
Not a convincing performance. City never really defeated the high press convincingly – three years to the day after they did so so iconically against Manchester City in the Premier League.
With Liam Gibbs and Isaac Hayden out injured they lack a defensive midfielder. Cantwell and Nunez provide the heartbeat of the team but need that security behind them.
But still, six on the bounce and still not playing at anything like the level they can achieve. For the other teams in the league, this must be frightening.
Well summed up James take 3pts anytime but it must be jammiest 6 wins ever only played well once in that six.dissjointed and mistake ridden all way through. First half gave ball away 7times on edge of our area four times in the second .defence needs major overhaul with Andrew o the exception not good enough for prem and struggling in championship sort it now Dean!
Thanks good piece, well covered. Same as I heard on the radio. As you say not playing at the best but still winning (just) cannot be bad. There will be more teams who come and set up the same way while others will park two buses. Better handling of these situations is needed
We’ve played better and lost, so what goes around comes around. A deliberate change in tactics that didn’t quite work or an off night by the team? But we won against a good opponent so no complaints from me.
It’s worrying that we seem to rest on our laurels for long periods during games as though our mere presence guarantees promotion. Hopefully Smith will knock this complaisant approach out of the team before Saturday.
I’d have to disagree with your comment that Todd Cantwell played well. His defensive work was dire and on several occasions he went missing leaving an overload on Byram. When Byram pointed this out to him he went into spread arms mode and waltzed around in no man’s land. I think Todd needs to take a leaf out of Kevin Keenan’s book and get on the weights as I don’t think he’s physically strong enough for football at this level. He’s too easy to knock off the ball and his tackling is ineffective.
It’s great that we achieved the right result in the end despite some dire refereeing and that it appears we’ve found the right sort of investment in Mark Anttanasio.
I’m fed up with saying this. We need a CENTRAL DEFENSIVE MIDFIELDER. (Two, preferably, as one is always likely to be injured.) Have been yelling this for years. Hello Norwich City? Can anyone hear me? The Skipp season apart, the lack of midfield bite and destroy has been beyond obvious. Not an elephant in the room, more like a diplodocus (wearing a replica 1992/93 kit – Gary Megson anyone?) Why doesn’t anyone at the club recognise it and solve it? CDM. CDM. CDM. Hello? Can anyone hear me? Perhaps I’m invisible… Hello?
Hi James
A typical city win some will say, but they will get turned over another in this league if they continue to lose concentration, showboating flicks and backheels shows disrespect for the opposition and a more physical team might have retaliated and caused a few more injuries to our squad.
Did BS deserve a point I think so as on the night they were our equal if not the better team and a few teams in and around us are improving so this isn’t going to be an easy season.
This league can be a war zone and city need to learn to play to the Whistle, be aware what’s going on around them both neglected for the second goal.
The big question if BS hadn’t scored would the Ref have gone back to the original foul or given a penalty and a possible sending off that could have changed the out come of the game.
Hi James
A pretty good summary of the game – a good 3 points but I felt Bristol will be very disappointed to leave with nothing.
I think the first minute probably summed up how the match would be played – straight after the kick off, Sargent was in a great position on the right but wasted the opportunity even with support in the box … and a handful of seconds later, Byram at left back passed the ball directly to a Bristol player on the corner of our box who had a chance but did not take it.
The high press from Bristol seemed to seriously cause us issues – and we panicked too often and gave sloppy passes away in and around our own box – Krul frequently kicked – something he does not usually do, but there was space behind their defence and Bristol were there for the taking but we failed to follow up on Pukki demonstrating how to pick them off
I think the missing piece is having a dominant midfield player who can grab the team by the scruff of the neck and dictate things. You mentioned Kenny being pulled to the right leaving space in the middle and Bristol used this space to dominate play at times – why was this not resolved on the pitch. Nunez does not speak a lot of English, so i would not expect him to be this player yet, but not for the first time, we had an open midfield inviting a team to attack our defence. I know Gibbs is out, but he is young and I fear not verbally dominant yet to order others to drop or to pull in from the left to cover holes. Hayden may be that player – but we have yet to see him … if City can get this bit right, I feel it will make a big difference to the solidity of the team and we would not end a game like we usually do sitting on the edge of our seats biting our nails.
Oh dear! What a pessimistic bunch.
We’ve just won 6 games on the spin without playing particularly well. That is as good a sign you’ll see that we will be there or thereabouts come the end of the season.
We haven’t even got out of second gear yet. When this teams starts to click, we are going to be a seriously tough team to play against.
Dose of reality is needed for a lot of fans.