• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

My Football Writer

My Football Writer Norwich City news… comment… analysis

Norwich City – news, comment and analysis

Find the best betting sites
  • Home
  • About us
  • The Team
  • Archives Index
  • Patreon
  • ADVERTISE
  • Contact us
Balancing the Books vs Playing the Market

Balancing the Books vs Playing the Market

2nd December 2023 By Gordon Christopher 12 Comments

Please share

Football’s Financial Models Compared

Thanks to all those who responded to my first article. Your only problem is you may have unleashed a monster… only time will tell.

While checking out some of the comments an idea sprang into my head about what we call, for want of a better term, the “self-funding” and the “buy/develop/sell” models. My first thought was ‘Are they not the same thing?’ so I asked that question and, with thanks to Tim Ball for taking the time to give me his thoughts, it led me to this article.

The interesting thing about this discussion is that City have been claiming to be one thing but may have slipped up trying to be the other. Allow me to explain.

Let’s start by clarifying the two models a bit.

Self-Funding – Steady as She Goes!

This is the financial equivalent of building a team like constructing a Lego masterpiece – piece by piece, with patience and precision. Clubs using this model rely on their own revenue streams – think match-day sales, broadcasting rights, and merchandising. It’s all about living within your means, much like most of us, as we try to balance our bank accounts.

The beauty of this model? Sustainability. Teams should not be throwing cash around like they’re trying to win a jackpot. Instead, they focus on nurturing young talent and making smart, calculated signings. Sure, this might mean they are not always splashing the cash on big names, but it’s like a slow-cooked meal – it takes time but the results can be deliciously rewarding.

Buy/Develop/Sell – The High Rollers

On the flip side, we have the ‘Buy/Develop/Sell Model,’ the financial equivalent of a high-stakes poker game. Here, clubs play the market – buying promising players, developing them, and then selling them for a tidy profit. It’s a bit like flipping houses only using footballers.

This model can be super exciting. Imagine signing a young unknown player and watching them blossom into the next big star – only to sell them for a huge profit! However, it’s risky – like betting big on red in roulette. If those player investments don’t pay off, clubs can find themselves in a financial pickle. (More on that later).

Impact on the Pitch

With the self-funding approach, you might see a team that grows together over time, which can be a heartwarming journey. But let’s be real – it can be frustrating when your team can’t compete with the financial heavyweights.

With buy/develop/sell it’s a rollercoaster. One season they might uncover a gem and soar up the table, and the next, they’re struggling because their star player has been sold. But when it works, it’s like hitting a jackpot – thrilling and potentially rewarding.

The big question is – which model is better in the long run? The self-funding model is like a stable investment – less glamorous, but with fewer heartaches. It aligns nicely with Financial Fair Play regulations, too. The buy/develop/sell model, though? It’s a bit of a gamble. High risk, but potentially high reward.

So, let’s take a look at some recent players. Jamal Lewis, the Murphy twins, and James Maddison, Andrew Omobamidele, Max Aarons and Todd Cantwell would all be examples of the self-funding model – all players brought through our academy and developed.

Even though he was a free signing, the wonderful Teemu Pukki was brought in as an established player and Emi Buendia was bought, so therefore, do they not fall into the buy/develop/sell model?

See what I mean about them being the same thing but different?

The conundrum is, if the Canaries are a self-funding club, how have we ended up with such a big debt (according to the most recent report – £82.7m) when the self-funding model is supposed to be more careful and less risky?

For me, it all seemed to go wrong at the start of our last trip to the Premier League. It looks like there was a conscious decision to change from self-funding to buy etc, which I am guessing was mainly brought about in an attempt to mitigate what happened during our previous visit to the EPL.

I have maintained in the past that we got promoted at least a year too early the first time around. Our self-funded, developing squad was too inexperienced and lightweight to make the grade, so the second time there was a decision to buy some players to bolster what we already had.

Let me also say, if this is the case, I completely understand what they were trying to do.

Unfortunately, instead of spending £60m on four or five players, they spent it on eight/nine players and basically ended up with nothing much better than what they already had, and the result was inevitable.

No, the self-funding model did not work! But I do not believe that it is unworkable.

The problem that must be overcome is that if you are developing a squad to go to the Premier League you cannot control when they are ready to make the step up. If you are top two in the Championship – up you go.

Both Norwich and Burnley walked the Championship. One is already relegated and the other is not far off.

I look forward to your thoughts on this, but for me, the fault with our current debt situation probably falls to Stuart Webber, who, despite some fantastic work, made some wrong decisions about incoming talent on this occasion.

This just demonstrates the fine line that people in his job really do walk. Had Webber got it right we would probably have stayed in the EPL and the whole debt issue would be irrelevant.

But he didn’t.


Please share

Filed Under: Column, Gordon Christopher

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Trev says

    2nd December 2023 at 8:11 am

    Excellent read. Thank you.

    Completely agree with where it went wrong and how. We should have signed fewer players with greater quality that summer.

    Was this where the debt was accrued though? Or was it in response to this? Did we borrow at the end of that season preparing Deano for the champ? Where and when did the money go?

    Reply
    • Gordon Christopher says

      2nd December 2023 at 9:24 am

      Thanks, Trev,
      I would have to check the documentation to be certain…maybe someone closer to NR1 could help us out there. Certainly, the money spent for the EPL season was wasted.

      Reply
  2. AlexB says

    2nd December 2023 at 12:34 pm

    Hi Gordon

    A very interesting read.

    We paid out record sums for youth players on both sides of the border hoping that one or more would be the next Maddison,Godfrey and most of those are now playing a league 1 or 2 clubs some aren’t in the professional game anymore.

    A few that were released have now started to look potential later developers so buying or recruiting to sell for a big profit is like high stake poker(I hate all card games).

    Another problem is that big better financed clubs were watching our recruitment department and picking off our talent spotters and we never recruited better or equal quality replacements.

    The rumours out were Farke and Kieran Scott wanted Pukki and Buendia but Webber didn’t and they worked overtime to convince him of the merits to sign them and look at those rewards.

    Selling players that other clubs want is easy and with Maddison, Buendia, Godfrey, Lewis and the Murphy twins we got good fees but most were at the club prior to Webbers arrival Buendia being the exception.

    Did we hold on to Aarons to long when bigger offers were on the table and was the sale of Cantwell really mishandled, another question did we over pay for players like Gibson, Sargent, Rashica and Tzolis possible again down to Webber’s ego for me.

    In a discussion I had with a few friends Webber wasn’t experienced enough to deal with Europe clubs and their Sporting Director with much more knowledge on how to manipulate the market for the highest value for their players.

    West Ham walked away from signing Rashica at £7m as to expensive yet City said it was a bargain at £9m similar other clubs were wary of Sargent at a similar fee, then there’s poor old Tzolis German clubs were interested but city went in high to ensure they signed him, a good friend once told me agents and European clubs look at all clubs in the UK’s Premiership as a means of survival and add extra millions to a price and city fell I to the trap.

    Every club hate to deal with Spurs and Levy who says they are self financing, they have a big debt due to a new stadium but that helps with all their sponsorship to be mostly self financing city don’t have the infrastructure to be self financing or the knowledge to be a buying and selling club due to the failure of increasing the stadium capacity and recruiting scouts to work along side the data to discover potential stars just like Brentford have done, City had first option on Toney, they looked at Watkins now at villa but the owners didn’t dug a little deeper to get them.

    Self financing is a gamble as is buying to sell and some times you need to listen to the scouts and go a little in to debt to buy an emerging gem for a future profit.

    Maybe with Attanasio will see some major changes in recruitment if Smith and Jones allow him to get involved

    1
    Reply
    • Gordon Christopher says

      3rd December 2023 at 2:52 am

      Hey Alex,

      I was very interested in the comments from Mr Attanasio that the selection of Ben Knapper was based on his use and knowledge od statistics, which is something he has had great success with in Milwaukee, Watching that space with interest.

      Reply
  3. David Bowers says

    2nd December 2023 at 12:55 pm

    The term “Self funding” has shape-shifted over the years to fit whatever sources of revenue we’ve had.

    Dramatic reduction in costs – self-funding
    High wage bills – self-funding
    Running a debt – self funding
    Running a profit – self funding
    Revenue predominantly from season tickets – self-funding
    Revenue predominantly from player sales – self-funding
    Revenue predominantly from TV revenues – self-funding
    Loans from a new shareholder – self-funding
    Asking fans to pay for training ground improvements – self-funding

    The only time it wouldn’t be self funding is if Delia had to open her purse. For a Labour supporter it sounds awfully like Conservative double-speak to me.

    2
    Reply
  4. John says

    2nd December 2023 at 6:31 pm

    Observation….Maddison we purchased from Coventry. He was never an NCFC Academy player.
    Also, you cannot budget for the “chicanery” taking place between other clubs.
    When Maddison was sold to Leicester a sell-on clause was included in his contract whereby City would receive a percentage of his next fee.
    Spurs (a self-funding club??) paid a lower reported fee of only £40m for Maddison and allowed Winks (value £10m) to join Leicester in part exchange…..so that Leicester would not have to pay NCFC such a large amount. OK, it was probably only £2m to £3m, but it could have helped the debt a little!!

    O T B C

    Reply
    • Gordon Christopher says

      3rd December 2023 at 7:23 am

      Fair comment RE Maddison – thanks for the correction.

      Reply
  5. AlexB says

    2nd December 2023 at 7:34 pm

    There’s an interesting article see below
    https://c.newsnow.co.uk/A/1207594813?-11057:808

    With some interesting comments from Attanasio saying the effose of self-funding is good and he wants to continue that

    “We look at the loans that come from us as self-funding,” Attanasio told the Pink Un. “One of the things that Delia and I were talking about after the meeting was that the plan is still to be self-funded.

    “We need to get a plan from Ben (Knapper) as to what he wants to achieve. We had some meetings today about how we can expand the stadium, and the training ground and all of that requires capital”

    Is he being extremely clever in away to get full control of the club, but I wouldn’t let Smith and Jones near any funding decisions after the way money has been wasted over the last couple of years

    1
    Reply
    • Gordon Christopher says

      3rd December 2023 at 7:20 am

      I read this story literally before coming here to check comments. I also found it very interesting and I think, in Ben Knapper, he may have found a kindred spirit.

      Reply
  6. Stewart Lewis says

    2nd December 2023 at 11:22 pm

    Thanks, Gordon – a very good analysis.

    A fair-minded person would conclude, I think, that some of Stuart Webber’s work was outstanding – even miraculous – but the transfer window after our second promotion was a disaster. After the first promotion we made a conscious decision to settle legacy debts and invest in our antiquated training facilities, but second time round we were in a position to strengthen the team and have a shot at staying in the top flight; our transfer dealing blew it.

    Ed Balls made the perspicacious observation that the self-funding model could work, but we had to get almost every decision right. We made some irredeemably bad ones in summer 2021.

    While impressions of the AGM are overshadowed by Delia’s unfortunate and inappropriate comment about “20% of fans”, what I found most interesting were Mark Attanasio’s interviews. He supports self-funding, under a new definition: borrowing and capital investment are fine if under our control, ie funded through those involved in the club. His associates like property developer Richard Ressler – who’s likely to take the second Board seat now available to Attanasio’s group – will clearly become increasingly important to us.

    Reply
    • Gordon Christopher says

      3rd December 2023 at 7:18 am

      Completely agree,

      But I do understand after years of frustration with some of the language used at her and Michael that at some point she might boil over a bit. It certainly wasn’t a good idea in the scheme of things.

      1
      Reply
  7. Gordon Christopher says

    3rd December 2023 at 2:50 am

    Thanks, David,

    I think this is why I was confused. They certainly do seem to overlap

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

As featured on NewsNow: Norwich City news” style=

Norwich City News 24/7

@NorwichCityFC Latest

norwichcityfc

Norwich City FC

@norwichcityfc ·
16h

PM25 💫

20

norwichcityfc

Norwich City FC

@norwichcityfc ·
17h

Good luck, Yellows! 🔰

Norwich City Women FC @NorwichCityWFC

Your starting XI to take on the Cherries 🟡🍒

Retweet on Twitter Norwich City FC Retweeted
norwichcitywfc

Norwich City Women FC

Verified account @norwichcitywfc ·
20h

Round 2️⃣ 👊@WomensFACup

norwichcityfc

Norwich City FC

@norwichcityfc ·
14 Nov

Five clean sheets in a row for Ruairi and Northern Ireland 💚👊

3

Copyright © 2026 21VC Ltd | All rights reserved | Not to be reproduced without prior permission.

Disclaimer: The information on this website consists of personal opinions. Whilst we have taken all reasonable steps to ensure that the information contained on these Web pages is accurate and correct at the time of writing we do not accept any liability whatsover for any loss or damage caused by reliance on this information.

We do not accept any responsibility for information contained in other websites to which this site links. We strongly advise users to check any information before acting or relying on it.

Developed and Hosted by