If you want certainty, look away now.
I could sign off this article “Perplexed of Hertfordshire” or “Confused of Abbots Langley”. Many questions, few clear-cut answers.
I’m not (yet) talking about Saturday’s meeting with Huddersfield, of course. That’s relatively easy to make sense of, compared to the bigger questions around the club.
Do we have a strong Championship squad, made to look average by inept coaching? Or an average Championship squad, whose limitations can’t be concealed by its coaches?
Do the players have belief in the coaching staff, or are they biding their time for change? Was our summer transfer business shrewd, given the financial constraints and imperatives, or a wasted opportunity?
While some have fixed views about these questions – and are welcome to hold forth in the comments – I’d contend the evidence is sufficiently mixed for some hesitation.
The AGM provided little clarity, except on two things:
- Special as she is, Delia could use some advice on diplomacy
- We can put to bed the silly notion that Mark Attanasio is going to defer to Delia and Michael until 2026. His wording was careful, “we’ll agree things”; they didn’t demur.
As to the coach and players, here’s my ambivalence.
Last season surely wasn’t a fair test of David Wagner. He should be judged, I argued, on the result of a summer transfer window and preseason.
And at first that result looked positive. Yes, our transfers increased the average age of the squad. But they did something more urgent and important: the additions of Jack Stacey, Shane Duffy and Ashley Barnes addressed our most obvious flaw last season, a lack of mental resilience and leadership.
The first six games were a revelation: a City side of purpose, fluency and belief. The failings since then can’t be overlooked – but nor, as I see it, should that start.
(By the way, the window also saw us make a big and necessary profit through the sales of Max Aarons, Milot Rashica and Andrew Omobamidele. That revenue was too late to be reflected in the current set of accounts.)
Injuries have hampered us, especially the loss of Josh Sargent. But no, Delia: they’re not enough to excuse the collapse in form after Rotherham.
A month ago, I was convinced Wagner should go; he seemed clueless to stop the rot, and the players’ performances didn’t speak of any belief in his tactics or selections.
Now, I can’t be so sure. Of course we haven’t returned to the fluency of the first half-dozen games, but 14 points from the last 7 games is a fact. If we were fortunate to win at Bristol City, we equally deserved more at home to Preston.
What’s characterised our performance in several of the games – and in spades at Portman Road – is a togetherness and will to battle. That, and the celebrations when we succeed, don’t suggest a team lacking commitment to their Head Coach.
So, a mixed bag. Can the upturn in results, together with the imminent return of Josh Sargent and Grant Hanley, breed a fresh confidence and verve in the players? The jury’s out on that one – and Saturday may give us a clue or two.
Sadly, we won’t have our regular pleasure of seeing Neil Warnock on the touchline. Having steered Huddersfield to safety last season, he signed a new contract – only to be replaced by the new American owners (hmm). Darren Moore has been in charge this season and just received a vote of confidence from the owners who say there’s “not even a consideration” of firing him (double hmm).
Huddersfield are clearly one of the weaker teams in the division, a stark contrast in style and quality to Ipswich. A check of their record should dispel any thought of complacency, though.
They’ve lost eight times this season – one fewer than we have. The only reason we’re in the top half while they’re closer to the bottom is draws: we’ve drawn only four, to their ten. They’ve also conceded fewer goals than we have.
Huddersfield’s recent speciality, home and away, is 1-1 draws. Though not prolific scorers across the season, they’ve scored at least once in each of their last six games: four 1-1s, a 3-1 defeat to Preston but an impressive 2-1 win at Sunderland.
Joint top scorers are Delano Burgzorg, a striker on loan from Mainz in Germany, and central defender Michal Helik.
I envisage a similar game to Preston, with Norwich trying to break down a Huddersfield team of limited ambitions. We’ll see whether City can be more successful this time.
I’m more confident with Borja Sainz established in the starting XI. The defensive side of his game has weaknesses, but if we’re to contend for the playoffs he surely has a major role to play. As has Josh Sargent when he returns – the sooner the better.
The last, but by no means least, word here. Wishing all our readers – including those who disagree with us – a very merry Christmas and a happy and successful 2024.
OTBC


Hi Stewart
I enjoyed the read after the line. Delia is special she might be many things, but for me and many others, that doesn’t describe her.
The Huddersfield Town Owners message to there supporters and those sentiments could how many feel about City right now see below.
Kevin Nagle (@KevinNagleMLS) December 13, 2023
“I don’t like to communicate when I’m angry/frustrated, but after taking a deep breath I can tell you that not only do I hear you as always, but I share your frustration.
“As I see it, supporters need something to support, and being honest – there’s not much there right now when it comes to results and entertainment on the pitch.
Darren Moore had to pick up from squad built for Warnock by Warnock so possibly will hope to recruit some players come the window opening and at the moment Blackpool are hoping he doesn’t recall Jordan Rhodes who seems to be getting a few goal for them on loan played 18 scored 14 in all competitions (couldn’t City do with him).
Is the jury still out on Wagner for many a cheap option when recruited but 2 small runs really covers up so many poor results since he arrived, has he lost the dressing room I’m not sure but I see players finding a little pride in themselves and that’s helping his cause in some areas of the supporters.
The Ipshite game hopefully will start a run over the Festive Period of good results but the question is would you risk getting players Wagner wants with a possible change in the coaching dept that happen sooner than later.
Like with the Ipshite game we will need strength of character to put the Terriers to the sword but have City got enough of that for two consecutive games I’m not sure on that.
Will a returning Hanley and Sargent help tern the tide to a more optimistic one and will Sorensen get time to earn a new deal playing as a Defensive Midfielder but Wagner doesn’t use a system with a DM so many questions and only two people that can answer them BK and Wagner, I just wonder when the review will be completed and will the pesky supporters ever find out those results.
Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year
Wagner’s contract ends on January 5th. Surely if the club were going to extend it we would have heard an announcement. I think we will be looking for a new manager in a week or so and I think Wagner knows this, it explains why he has carried on through the poor performances and makes financial sense. So pretty soon Knapper will start to have an influence with his contacts and ideas, it’ll be a fresh start with hopefully most of the squad fit. Wagner can leave without any animosity, he joined when the first team was in a mess, he has improved some players, Smith would not have given Rowe a chance, more likely loaned him out and bought in another Villa youngster. Wagner’s results with a full squad have been very good, so injuries are more of a reason than an excuse for bad results because he had no plan B.
Perhaps I’m wrong but if not let’s hope Wagner can go out in style with the results getting better and some optimism and positivity beginning to show..
.
Hi Gil
Wagner is on a rolling contract and it automatically renews on the anniversary of the original signing date so no announcement is really needed, there will be an agreed increase or end 9f contract payment if the club decides enough is enough.
The big problem could be compensation for all the remaining backroom staff unless they are kept on by any new incoming coach.
Isn’t it fun being a City supporter
A rolling contract means exactly what it says, a year’s notice at any time. Any reference to the first anniversary is therefore irrelevant.
I was on a rolling contract for many years with different companies and it was always stated that a 1 month notice was the norm and it could be ended by either part at any time
.Meaning of rolling contract in English
a contract that continues until someone decides to end it, rather than one that continues until a particular date: You may be asked to consider whether you prefer a rolling contract, i.e. one which continues until the required period of notice is given. Compare.
What are the rules for a rolling contract?
With rolling contracts, the tenancy can be brought to an end by either party, at any time, as long as the required notice period (normally two months) is given. A rolling contract does have the benefit that neither party need do anything unless they want to end the tenancy, which can be useful in certain circumstances.
I heard that it is a 12 month rolling contract which will renew after a year unless either party decides against it.
Didn’t smith give Rowe his debut in the PL?
Yes but just after an injury and chasing lost causes. Then decided he preferred Springett.
Like yourself, Stew, I also thought that it was unfair to judge Wagner on last season’s results, as disappointing as they were. He definitely needed a full pre-season and a summer transfer window before it could be considered as his team.
That said, the jury still remains out for me. The recent uptick in results, as welcome as they’ve been, don’t seem to be matched with performances. If they don’t improve to substantiate the results, then it feels like things will go backwards for him and a serious push for the playoffs will evaporate.
Until the club moves into the next phase of ownership and investment I can’t see things improving to the point of a sustained stay in the Premiership. We can change managers, bring in a level of player. who if they show any promise or excel will eventually be sold. We will in the meantime be at our very best a yo-yo club.