It’s a conundrum.
As it stands both scenarios are eminently possible. It’s looking increasingly likely that we will be in the playoffs, but from there, who knows?
The scuttlebutt from ‘sources’ is that the club is £90m in the red, but that the debt is covered by Mark Anastassio as a private, not a public, debt. Be that as it may, that’s a load of moolah but, hey, promotion via the playoffs is worth gazillions.
Well, at least enough to theoretically cover the debt and still leave some spending money. Quite how much spending money is not clear but let’s say it’s £50million. That might just about get you a trio of proven Premier League performers, but it’s obvious to everyone that this team will need more than three imports if it goes up.
Would Mark A open the chequebook, a la Nottingham Forest and splurge a fortune, running the risk of breaking every financial sustainability rule in the book? (If you still finish outside of the bottom three after a points deduction it’s a win-win innit).
I don’t think for a second he would, so we are then crossing our fingers and hoping that David Wagner can keep the team up for the first season – doing a Huddersfield in other words – and then investing in the second season knowing that a further £120m is incoming.
If promotion happens and we don’t invest – the most likely scenario – the probable outcome is another season of resignation followed by another relegation. But the majority of the debt should be cleared and then parachute money can then help a renewed attempt to return to the Promised Land.
And around we go again…
The other option is a failure to progress through the playoffs, Championship football again, and no big bung of money. If this is to be the outcome we will see a summer of churn, with Josh Sargent, Gabi Sara, and Jon Rowe (and maybe others) being the subject of offers that would be simply too good to turn down.
It’s a book we’ve read before.
But it’s not just players that could be in the churn. Mr Wagner’s failure to take the team up could be the deciding factor for Mr Knapper, who may then choose to change his head coach. If that happens, it’s a case of who comes in and when, and does any recruitment occur before a new coach is in place?
On that score, it could be a hectic couple of months!
So do we want to go up? Yes, please. We want to play against the best. Even if we can’t afford to get in the playing staff that gives us a fighting chance of staying up.
Not going up will only increase the debt and see some of our best players leave, only to be replaced by… who knows?
We have attracted plenty of underperforming players while being in the Premier League but, generally, they are usually of a higher quality than players that can be brought into an ambitious Championship team – Ricky van Wolfswinkle, Christos Tzolis, and Marcus Normann to name but three.
So, I’m concluding that we can’t afford to be promoted with our current funding model, but that we can’t afford not to be promoted either.
Tricky, right?


We won’t know the level of debt until November and even then it will be 5 months out of date. Hopefully the Attanassio deal is finalised by then as that reduces the debt somewhat. At the end of last season the debt was enough of a problem that we couldn’t pay dividends, this is significant. Up to now the issue has been lack of cash and spending more than we earn before player trading. I believe that 99% of clubs make losses and have debts but they are funded by owners, FFP is not FFP meaning its not fit for purpose. Owners can write off debt, owners can buy the stadium, owners can pay £200 for every season ticket sold and can fund away travel. These are all things EFL clubs do. However, it appears that they can’t fund an increase in squad value after promotion, I believe this is Forest’s problem. FFP doesn’t stop teams doing a Derby or a Bolton but they do stop them doing a Villa.. Overall, yes we can’t afford to go up but we definitely can’t afford to stay down
Yes John, as my Old Bradenham aunt used to say it’s a real buggers muddle .
Hi Bernie
An interesting read.
It the devil and the deep blue sea.
We can’t afford promotion and we can’t afford not to be promoted and as you say this operating model doesn’t and has never worked.
It at times given us short-term success but has also shown us the failure of it to league one.
Our present ownership model is either they can’t see the word for the trees or possibly ignoring a business model that’s unfit for purpose.
We would all like clubs to be run within there means and the lack of funding via increasing CR capacity over the years has hurt city in many ways.
Let’s hope the Attanasios confirmation happens sooner than later but we will still have no clear ownership and that’s going to create it’s own problems.
An excellent read and good comments.
Its plain to see that it cannot carry on in its current guise, one which has plunged it into previously unheard of levels of debt and left it in thrall to the Attanasio family.
If, as is most likely, we fail to achieve promotion, a continuation of the status quo will necessitate a fire sale, which will put last summers in the shade.
Raiding the squad to pay the bills has been the M.O. of this ownership “model” for years now but the loss of Sara, Sargent, Rowe et al would undermine the progress made this season and take us back to the dark days of championship struggle.
I’m sure I speak for most of the support when I state that it’s high time the prevarication and general fannying about is brought to a close and certain individuals start to put the club before their personal preferences.
The feeling is that Attanasio will not fully commit to the club until such a time as he has assumed control. He is the best hope of hanging on to some of our crown jewels and attempting to build a football team, which is the point of the exercise. Ownership for ownerships sake is not in the best interests of the club.
Self funding has failed, anyone with a modicum of common sense can see that.
Good post, Chris. Even Mr Webber – Delia’s top prefect – conceded by the time he departed that modern football and self-funding are not compatible.
Good piece Bernie.
Sheffield United have conceded not far off 3 goals per game this season and we have conceded 1.5 in the Champo, so rather than the excitement we have had in past years if we do go up then it will be laced with a lot of fear😱😱😱
I subscribe to this, it will be far better for the long term interests of the club to go up.
Despite whatever we face next season.
Quite how we are £97 million in debt I don’t know, at this point our majority shareholder would say “you know nothing about running a football club” and she would be 100% correct, I haven’t a clue.
But by reaching this unbelievable deficit neither does she. She is the one with the “Self-funding Mantra” If you live by Self-funding you have to take the consequences when it fails and do the decent thing and hand the reins over to Mark Attanasio.
Talking of MA, what the hell are the EFL doing ? Some quite unsuitable people have been found to be “fit and proper” over the last few years. How the hell did the Reading chap get through?
Marl Attanasio is a very successful businessman from a country that is a democracy, surely this is a mere formality. I really hope there aren’t people from within the club who are trying to stop this from happening.
If what Delia and Michael had been telling us for the last ten years that no one (there were three other bids for Mr Foulger’s shares) was interested in “little” old us then you wouldn’t have heard a peep from me criticising the board.
But we now know that wasn’t true. And it came from the board that it wasn’t true.
So we need MA far more than we need any of the board members. Just ask this question… What if MA walks away and wants his money back ? This why today Delia and Michael would not be allowed to be shareholders as I read it.
As MA has taken on this debt does this mean we won’t be liable to any EFL fine or points deductions next season or the season after if we do not go up?
We do really need more communications from the club, after all it wasn’t those pesky, ungrateful fans who racked up a £97 million debt.
If we don’t go up MA’s decisions will be interesting, does he try to keep the majority of his best players for a real go next season or does he sell and use the money to buy younger players and therefore build a lot slower?
So Bernie I really think that promotion and all its genuine worries are real but the alternative is a lot worse, especially with this huge debt.
I do not think for one minute DW or BK think that the defence we have now would be in anyway good enough for the EPL. Personally I think there will be a rebuild (big or small depending on MA) in the summer whatever league we are in or whoever the coach is.
I’d love to subscribe to the anything can happen club but we’ve been here before.. I don’t have the stomach for another season of unmitigated torture. This team isn’t anywhere near as good as the two previous promotion sides and our recruitment for the Premier league has been pretty mutch 100% failure. There seem to be a reasonable crop of youngsters coming through I’d be more inclined for a reset from top to bottom and give some of them a chance. Quite how we got 90m in debt whilst selling our best player and replacing him with mediocre championship players is beyond me. I’d guess its because we paid Premier league wages to players performing at championship levels. That’s all water under the bridge.
Sorry Bernie , although I agree with much of what you say , your sums do not add up for me .Promotion is estimated to be worth approximately £150 million , depending on where the team finishes in the table . Last time NCFC were in the PL there wage bill was around £90 million ( the third lowest of the league) Agents fees took that total to over the £100 million mark . Any PL league standard player will probably cost £10+ million even sourcing unknowns from overseas . That doesn’t lève much for reducing debt . Unfortunately the PL realistically consists of 3 leagues & Norwich would almost certainly be in the relegation scrap division. Not much fun as we along with other recently promoted clubs will testify.
The financial muscle of teams like Chelsea ( who probably will end the season empty handed ) can never be matched by NCFC , . A £90 million debt may be small change , used to pay off agents fee to the likes of Chelsea, but to NCFC it’s a millstone around its neck , restricting investment both on & off the field .. Perhaps we supporters just have to accept the highs & lows of a continuous cycle of exciting promotion seasons & the reality that brings with a season or 2 in the PL . GREED is everything for established PL clubs , as the league tables & sacrifice of FA Cup traditions proves .
The 3 promoted clubs from last season will probably all get relegated with a combined points total that is less than the 4 th place team qualifying for the lucrative European Circus .. Ultimately football is a passion for most supporters , enjoying the good times living in hope in the other . Always been like that for me with Norwich & will continue to be so , whether it’s League One struggles with Gunn or back to back promotions with Lambert & DF , although my favourite era was probably the Stringer one
Some posters on here have a possible lack of understanding for FFP or indeed as it is called P&S.
1) New owners do not change the Position as such. Nothing like a Reset.
2) Debt Writeoffs impact the FFP/P&S position only in so far as say £10m written off at 10% Interest..£1m in Interest payments no longer adds to losses.
3) Fixed Asset sales since 2021 are excluded from the P&S Calculation ie the Year Adjusted Earnings Before Tax.
4) To 2023-24 it was £61m plus Allowables, now it is £39m (or £41.5m plus Allowables).
5) Point 2 to follow up, it may show say £50m of Debt Written Off in the Profit or Loss Before Tax but it is adjusted out of the calculations.