• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

My Football Writer

My Football Writer Norwich City news… comment… analysis

Norwich City – news, comment and analysis

Find the best betting sites
  • Home
  • About us
  • The Team
  • Archives Index
  • Patreon
  • ADVERTISE
  • Contact us
The owner may sympathise with our wish – but practicalities get in the way

The owner may sympathise with our wish – but practicalities get in the way

11th November 2025 By Stewart Lewis 10 Comments

Please share

It’s no secret I’d like to see the back of Ben Knapper.

If Liam Manning had to go – as he did – there’s an even stronger case against Ben. 

Hallmarks of a good manager in any organisation are sound judgement, openness and consistency; he’s conspicuously fallen short on each point.

Unlike some, I don’t believe Mark Attanasio is blind to these failings. Not only did he carefully avoid any praise for Ben in his phone-in, he linked his fate to that of Manning.

It may well be that Attanasio, like many of us, is chary of letting Ben choose another Head Coach.

However, there’s a practical problem. A Head Coach is easy to fire. The interim between Head Coaches, though, is a distinctly awkward time to lose your Sporting Director.

We know Mark Attanasio believes in a systematic process to make senior appointments. Let’s say it was during his recent visit that he decided, barring a dramatic upturn in form, that change would be necessary in this international break.

It’s improbable he could have a new Sporting Director identified, assessed and lined up. So it’s a process that, however quickly everyone would like it to happen, would take a while.

The knock-on effect of that delay on getting a new Head Coach in place is unthinkable. The only solution would be Celtic’s approach of a stopgap appointment.

Even if there were a logical candidate, I don’t believe it’s an option that would appeal to Attanasio.

So it’s as a necessary expedient, rather than an ideal choice, that Ben Knapper is being tasked with appointing another Head Coach.

Not just for himself, but for Mark Attanasio and his interests, Ben will need to get this one right.

The first thing Ben – and to an extent Mark – should perhaps do is swallow some of their pride and go against some of their natural inclinations.

Mark likes to delegate authority to his executives; this time, he needs to ask constant and searching questions.

Ben likes a passive Head Coach who won’t question his actions or recruitment methods; this time, he should accept a more assertive one.

At this point, the new Head Coach – perhaps we might even call him a manager – has to be a clear and strong character. A personality who’ll gee up the players and challenge the club’s hierarchy.

One sacred cow that shouldn’t remain sacred is the planning of transfer windows.

The data-led approach to recruitment planning is close to Ben Knapper’s heart, and to Mark Attanasio’s. It’s a fine theory, but it needs to be held to dispassionate scrutiny. In particular, two tests:

. are we creating the continuity in coaching and playing style that’s necessary for it to be effective?

. does its track record offer reassurance that it’s producing quality and value for money?

It’s too early to make definitive judgements on some of Knapper’s recent signings. But he clearly hasn’t ensured the degree of continuity to satisfy the first question. And right now, it’s hard to argue a positive answer to the second.

Our January targets will already have been assessed and planned. If I were a candidate for the Head Coach job, though, I’d insist on a review and significant input.

The new Head Coach will have ideas of the kind of player we need to claw our way up the division. Its track record doesn’t inspire confidence that our locked-in, data-driven plans are fit for purpose.

I doubt Ben will take kindly to any such interference in his plans, but I’d be more hopeful of Mark Attanasio. Successful business people scrutinise outcomes as well as inputs; results as well as processes.

However fond they are of theories and processes, good leaders will adjust them in the light of results. (Unlike, apparently, Russell Martin as a Head Coach).

Now, I’ve no idea whether any of this is happening. But it seems to me it should. While I have little faith in Ben Knapper to show either humility or flexibility, I’ve more confidence in our owner.

For now, the change of Head Coach has, of course, turned the spotlight on Knapper. It shouldn’t, however, deflect from the broader issue.

The running of our club is, and has been for some time, an error-strewn mess.

It’s something from which Zoe Webber can’t escape responsibility – though that often seems her first and main instinct.

The last time City needed a shake-up on this scale was 2009 after relegation to League One. Delia and Michael’s appointment of David McNally and David’s appointment of Paul Lambert were revolutionary and uncomfortable. But they did the trick.

Comfortable continuity surely isn’t the right option now.


Please share

Filed Under: Column, Stewart Lewis

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Cyprus Canary says

    11th November 2025 at 1:14 pm

    Yes my view is that we have no choice but to stick with Knapper for this appointment but hopefully Mark Attanasio will take some council from his contacts elsewhere in the game. I would be surprised if Ben can survive in the longer term. Certainly not if we fail to turn the ship around and avoid relegation.
    I still believe that there are enough decent players in our squad to do that under the guidance of a manager with a plan.
    BUT who will that be?

    3
    Reply
    • Stewart Lewis says

      11th November 2025 at 1:53 pm

      Thanks, Cyprus. Of the candidates mooted so far, Gary O’Neil seems to me the most likely to get us going in the right direction.

      3
      Reply
      • Canaryjim says

        11th November 2025 at 2:31 pm

        I quite like the sound of this Marek Papszun took a 3rd div team upto the top and stayed there and his win rate is very impressive .

        1
        Reply
        • AlexB says

          11th November 2025 at 3:01 pm

          Hi Jim

          When Thorup was recruited he had a backroom team foisted upon him that didn’t know his methods and then Knapper recruited Riddersholm as his assistant neither had experience of the Championship.

          We’ve seen novices do well in the Championship given time and a coaching team that are aligned to the Head Coaches methods ie Farke.

          So if the Polish gentleman is to get the position then he needs the right team to back him not a bunch of ex Arsenal and Brighton flops.

          2
          Reply
  2. AlanF says

    11th November 2025 at 2:41 pm

    Perfect summary of the club’s dilemma, Stewart.
    But consider this:
    Knapper has now completely messed up player recruitment as well as appointing two failed managers, not to mention the unnecessary sale of Nunez to Ipswich (of all clubs!) when we are desperately short of creative midfielders.
    .The man is clearly incompetent.
    If he gets it wrong again (as he is likely to), the consequences would be disastrous.
    And what exactly does Zoe Webber bring to the club? Nothing, as far as can be discerned from the outside.
    My view is that Attanasio needs to take decisive action and make a clean sweep now.
    If Knapper stays, the situation will only become more dire.

    8
    Reply
  3. AlexB says

    11th November 2025 at 2:42 pm

    Hi Stewart

    Another excellent read.

    If we believe the ever changing list of contenders then I’m not over confident we will get out of this God damn awful mess.

    Too many from the failed previous regime are still in place, that’s down to no complete du diligence being done by the Attanasio Group unless that was part of the handover agreement.

    As I said in a previous comment I hope the Bromby and Partners haven’t a hand in City’s selection process for the Head Coach or a possible Sporting Director !

    Did Knapper make his biggest mistake in firing Thorup or maybe not giving Wilshere a chance on both only time will tell

    Going the cheap way hiring someone who’s unemployed is possibly the quickest but it’s not always the most prudent, Attanasio said Manning was 1st, 2nd and 3rd on his list then said others were interviewed and the Pink-un says Gary O’Neil was one of them if he was good enough then what’s changed ?

    As you describe we need an experienced manager that can galvanise the squad and supporters not someone on the current list does than.

    Breaking News
    Swansea sack Alan Sheehan so that’s another that could soon be added to City’s list

    2
    Reply
  4. Bernard Owen says

    11th November 2025 at 5:23 pm

    Wonder if Delia is on the phone to her old friend Roy. As a favour to Mark.
    Just short term , and let him coach the first team and produce a private report on the quality of Ben Knappers transfer incomings for Mark.
    That’s if a short term sticking plaster is needed.

    3
    Reply
    • Nigel says

      13th November 2025 at 11:45 am

      Why would we want Roy ? why would he come ? If we are going short term then go and get Big Sam – pay whatever it takes mostly on delivery of survival – that leaves 6 months to get a new SD and manager.

      Reply
  5. Former away season ticket holder says

    11th November 2025 at 5:45 pm

    Ben Knapper has wasted – there’s no other word for it – so many City millions, which will doubtless have 11% interest charged on them as well, that he should have no say in the matter at all. At best he should provide a list of possible candidates to Mark Attanasio and that should be the end of his involvement.

    Frankly the man should have last been seen leaving Carrow Road carrying a cardboard box with his personal effects. That’s what would happen to an executive at any other similarly-sized multi-million-pound operation after such a disastrous period in charge.

    There seems to be an awful lot of optimism around that we’re going to appoint a well-known name with a bit of experience under his belt. I find it hard to believe that’s really going to happen. Are your O’Neils, Martins or even – though I think this one is totally unlikely – Rodgers going to work under Knapper? Can’t see it myself, and surely they’d be wanting more of a budget than Norfolk Holdings are willing to offer after a lot of recent expenditure.

    I feel Attanasio doesn’t realise the danger City are in. We are not an attractive project – is, say, even Dave Challinor really going to leave well-funded Stockport to come here?. We have distinct structural issues, an imbalanced squad which is woefully ill-equipped to deal with a relegation fight and the new man faces a honeymoon period which will be measured in days. Should we appoint someone by the end of the international break he’s got a free hand away to Birmingham on November 22, but he has to get four points over the following seven days at home to Oxford and QPR or we’re in serious danger of getting cut adrift. And although Knapper would cop most of the flak for that, some would see the new manager as being guilty by association just for being the sporting director’s man.

    It’s certainly not going to be a comfortable few months, that’s for sure.

    3
    Reply
  6. Thomo says

    11th November 2025 at 6:12 pm

    Personally I’d pull the trigger on Kapper and Webber

    For me I’d like to see Rob Newman in the role speaks well been in the game long enough and genuinely understands the club and supporters add Gary ONeil as manager and someone who has been around the block as his no 2

    This for me works oh and get rid of most of the sports science football is about goals and players giving the fans 100% nothing else matters!

    3
    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

As featured on NewsNow: Norwich City news” style=

Norwich City News 24/7

@NorwichCityFC Latest

norwichcityfc

Norwich City FC

@norwichcityfc ·
21h

Cool as you like 😮‍💨

3

norwichcityfc

Norwich City FC

@norwichcityfc ·
22h

We will remember them 💛

2

norwichcityfc

Norwich City FC

@norwichcityfc ·
22h

Effective in both boxes 👊

norwichcityfc

Norwich City FC

@norwichcityfc ·
23h

Won it, scored it, love it 🎯

Copyright © 2026 21VC Ltd | All rights reserved | Not to be reproduced without prior permission.

Disclaimer: The information on this website consists of personal opinions. Whilst we have taken all reasonable steps to ensure that the information contained on these Web pages is accurate and correct at the time of writing we do not accept any liability whatsover for any loss or damage caused by reliance on this information.

We do not accept any responsibility for information contained in other websites to which this site links. We strongly advise users to check any information before acting or relying on it.

Developed and Hosted by