• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

My Football Writer

My Football Writer Norwich City news… comment… analysis

Norwich City – news, comment and analysis

Find the best betting sites
  • Home
  • About us
  • The Team
  • Archives Index
  • Patreon
  • ADVERTISE
  • Contact us
More layers to be added but Clement steering City toward calmer waters

More layers to be added but Clement steering City toward calmer waters

15th December 2025 By James Colman 22 Comments

Please share

Regular MyFootbalWriter readers may recall an epic journey I made in order to get to Coventry a while ago. Unbelievable as it seems, that was three managers ago.

This week’s journey was not quite such a distance, but still remarkable.

I started Saturday in Doha, with a schedule that got me back with enough time to get home and watch City’s lunchtime kick-off on TV, but not enough time to get to NR1.

My pre-flight attempts to sleep in the daytime were interrupted by a rapid-fire series of emails and messages, the net effect of which was that our departure had been brought forward by a couple of hours.

On the off chance, I dropped a message on the ‘Norwich City Tickets’ Facebook page, and within a few minutes, I had three or four offers. I took the first person to reply, and in short order, an electronic ticket landed in my Apple Wallet.

There were a few nervous moments in the night flight back – the possibility of fog at Luton Airport for a start – but we made it back, landing at 7am. Time enough to get home, change (not forgetting my newly christened ‘lucky’ scarf – I bought it in the Club shop before the QPR game) and even time for a 15-minute snooze before driving into the City.

It was only then that I really looked to see where I was sitting, to see that I had a seat in the Geoffrey Watling Stand – the City Stand to most of us. 

This pleased me because, since I’ve been able to attend home games again regularly, I have been in all the other stands, except the City Stand.

I had only been that side of the pitch once before, and to my surprise and delight, I was in almost the same spot.

That occasion was March 6th, 1985. The astute (i.e. old) of you will realise that this was the Milk Cup semi-final against Ipswich, but also that this took place five months after the City Stand was largely destroyed by fire.

Confession time. One of my more dubious claims to fame was that at the time, I was a member of 231 (Norwich) Sqn of the Air Training Corps, and I was part of the marching band that played on the pitch before the game and at half-time!

Amusingly, the ‘plumes’ that adorned our berets were usually (for unknown reasons) blue and white, but we thought it prudent to swap them for a yellow and green variety for this game.

They were the days of Robert Chase, and with a sell-out predicted, he wasn’t going to surrender 25 or 30 valuable seats to us; hence, we ended up in the derelict remains of the stand. 

If you have the VHS of that game, you can catch occasional glimpses of us.

We were, incidentally, invited back to play at other games, except then, in his wisdom, Robert Chase elected to put us in the Barclay – in the empty section that segregated home and away fans. 

This was in the era of the fruit netting that was supposed to stop fans from throwing items on the pitch, so needless to say, we all huddled as close to the City fans as we could!

Anyway, back to the matter in hand.

City, of course, beat Southampton, and as I got to my car in County Hall Car Park, just about the first caller I heard on Canary Call was a lady who commented that we were all criticising Ben Knapper’s signings for being rubbish, but now we should give credit where credit was due because they all look so much better.

That is a fair and valid point. The team that started against Southampton were all Knapper signings, with the exception of Kenny McLean and Kellen Fisher.

Or were they?

The man on most people’s lips, and the one that the caller specifically referenced, was Pelle Mattsson. 

True enough, Knapper eventually signed him after bizarrely pulling out of the deal for the sake of a few hundred thousand pounds. 

But it was Johannes Hoff Thorup who pointed Knapper in the direction of the man already dubbed the Danish Gary Holt.

Another of the starting XI, Oscar Schwartau, was similarly recommended by JHT – as was substitute Marcondes, for that matter.

Harry Darling was signed at the request of Liam Manning, which leaves six of Saturday’s starters directly attributable to Knapper.

During his recent Radio Norfolk interviews, Mark Attanasio referenced the fact that our scouting system was very good at identifying UK-based players, and that we knew everything about them before they put pen to paper, but that we didn’t have such granularity with overseas players – something the acquisition of src ftbl is presumably going to rectify.

Of the six, Ruairi McConville, Ben Chrisene, Jacob Wright, and, of course, ‘Hand of Jov’ Makama were all UK-based, and few would dispute their positions in the team.

Which leaves just Vladan Kovacavic and Amankwah Forson.

I like Vlad – largely because of his character. His reaction at full-time on Saturday shows how invested he is in the team. He will concede silly goals, but over a season, probably save more.

And as for penalties… although maybe credit goes to McLean on Saturday. If you haven’t seen it, watch it back and watch Kenny tell Vlad which way to dive.

Forson looks like a player looking for a position. There is no disputing his work ethic and his pace. He frequently makes the wrong choice of final ball, though. There is a player in there, but he is too lightweight in the middle of the park, and, for now, looks like he is filling in on the right by default.

So on the face of it, we are better at signing UK-sourced players – hopefully Knapper will take note of this during January when he has what must surely be his last roll of the dice in the transfer window.

But I can’t end on that note.

We have just completed a week where we took an extremely creditable draw at Bramall Lane – which we coulda shoulda won – and then out-fought and outplayed an in-form Southampton side who were the second best team I have seen at Carrow Road this season.

The best, of course, being the team that beat them.

I said after the Watford game that, in order to avoid relegation, as a minimum, Clement needed to repeat his first three results for every set of three games for the rest of the season:

Lose. Draw. Win. All the way until May. Well, against the odds this time last week, he’s done set two. Six games. Eight points. 1.3 points per game.

Next three? Preston (a), Charlton (h) and Watford (h). Lose, draw, win in that lot, anyone?

In his post-match press conference on Saturday, Clement mentioned that as he builds more layers onto the work he has done so far, the trick is making sure that the players don’t forget the first points that he made.

The new manager bounce is statistically over after six games, so let’s see what happens next.

In the meantime, I direct you to ‘Turn The Corner’ by Slim Gambill, which seems suitably uplifting to reflect the current mood!


Please share

Filed Under: Column, James Colman

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. AlexB says

    15th December 2025 at 12:24 pm

    Well, according to Dermot Gallagher, Makama’s second was a handball and shouldn’t have been given from the camera angle he showed. There wasn’t a side angle that showed it came off his knee first, or at least it possibly did.

    I’ve never been a VAR enthusiast – I much prefer that one man makes a decision, win, lose or draw. It makes the game more interesting for supporters after the game.

    Forson was, I think, another that JHT knew about via the Go Ahead Eagles.

    I was pleased to hear Clement mention that young Emmanuel Adegboyega has started training with the first team after a long injury he got in pre-season – let’s hope he impresses enough for City to take up his option as he looked a good prospect at Dundee last season.

    I spent 2 years in Doha living in the Ezdan Tower, and loved the Friday all-inclusive brunch at different hotels every week – all before the World Cup and my retirement.

    Anyway, Saturday showed that with the right coaching, we actually have a team, and that Manning was the wrong coach at the wrong time.

    Maybe he’ll reflect on his time at City and take what he’s learnt into his next job and kick-start his career.

    Question: has anyone seen where Tony Roberts went after he left to take up a new position?

    Ho, Ho, Ho 🎅🎅🎅

    OTBC

    1
    Reply
  2. sgncfc says

    15th December 2025 at 12:51 pm

    Talk about re-writing history!

    What a dreadful article. Ben Knapper can’t really win can he? After 4 months of increasingly violent criticism directed at him from everywhere, including from this site, that he has “wasted £50m” and bought dreadful players, which was solely down to him and his useless data driven recruitment, now that some of those players are showing that they’re not actually useless they are apparently no longer his players!

    Clearly he made mistakes with choosing his first two coaches, but we seem now to be saying that the players he has signed are not only OK, but some of them are potential club legends! Obviously though, only the ones that JHT recommended.

    Never let the facts get in the way of sensationalist claptrap, sorry, journalism.

    How about an article with a very bold headline which starts with: AN APOLOGY TO BEN KNAPPER

    Or does this site, and this writer, not have the cojones?

    I was not alone in suggesting that we couldn’t tell how good the players were until they were coached by someone who knew what they were doing. Manning clearly wasn’t that coach and Knapper recognised that quicker than he was allowed to act on it by Absentasio.

    He’s not blameless for where we are – but for heaven’s sake give him the credit he now deserves for at least starting to turn it around.

    The flak he and his family have taken is beyond sense. and some people should be thoroughly ashamed of themselves.

    2
    Reply
    • AlexB says

      15th December 2025 at 1:59 pm

      That’s a great suggestion if you can find enough for an article instead of suggesting that someone else write it why don’t you instead of throwing your dummy out of the pram.

      James writes a weekly article that are well thought out and like everyone else has his right to an opinion !

      Write something that’s constructive if you don’t agree with his opinions and show some cojones yourself and write an article.

      1
      Reply
      • sgncfc says

        15th December 2025 at 2:58 pm

        I’ve written articles for this site and I’ve also regularly commented on some very good ones.

        This isn’t one.

        1
        Reply
        • Gary Gowers says

          15th December 2025 at 3:16 pm

          You’ve written for MFW?

          Presumably not under your nom de plume?

          ***

          Ahhh … think I’ve sussed it.

          Well, for balance, you’re more than welcome to pen another article in the defence of Ben Knapper. He could do with a cheerleader, right now.

          1
          Reply
          • Trev says

            16th December 2025 at 9:03 am

            Just in case anyone’s linking me to this…. nope.

            Regards, the real Trev Demo

    • JohnF says

      15th December 2025 at 2:35 pm

      As it was explained in the article the best signings were down to JHT and Manning leaving Knapper responsible for the very costly failures, no need for an apology.
      Very enjoyable read James.

      3
      Reply
      • sgncfc says

        15th December 2025 at 3:13 pm

        The “best signings”?? which ones are they then – just the ones now playing well I guess. And obviously, everything emanating from Denmark must be down to JHT (evidence? Just because he’s Danish?), who of course was sacked for not performing, and any good ones not from Denmark are down to Manning (evidence?) also sacked for not performing, and everyone who is still rubbish must be down to Knapper. Obviously including the Danish Slimane because he’s not been very good.

        What will it take for you to acknowledge that you might be wrong?

        Who signed Makama? Or is he not one of the best signings? Who persuaded Darling to join us instead of several other teams in the Championship? Who signed McConville? Chrisene? Diallo – again in the face of severe competition?

        Knapper is solely responsible for the “very costly” failings then. Which ones specifically? Apart from Jurasek I’m struggling to think of any.

        1
        Reply
        • JohnF says

          15th December 2025 at 6:32 pm

          The costly signings are Jurassic and Carnac with a combined spend of £16m. For this level of expenditure in the championship you expect far more than they have produced.
          Don’t forget he fired Wagner, a manger who ended in the top six and replaced him in succession with Thorup and Manning who were not only less successful but left us with the huge expenditure of long term contracts.
          I don’t think his level of performance would be tolerated in the majority of businesses with a similar turnover to Norwich City. I wouldn’t be surprised if he’s quietly move sideways and more responsibility for the playing side given to Clement.

          2
          Reply
    • James Colman says

      15th December 2025 at 2:43 pm

      Thanks for your comments – I’d like you to elaborate why you feel it is ‘dreadful’?

      I’ve laid out which of the team that started yesterday were signings that Knapper can claim full responsibility for. I’ve stated that he has had success sourcing those from the U.K. His picks from overseas leagues are so far largely less proven – for reasons stated in the article.

      My writing on these pages is done strictly as an amateur. I’m entitled to my opinions about matters at Carrow Road, and Gary is good enough to provide me a platform to air them on a weekly basis.

      You too are entitled to your opinions and I’m sure Gary would happily give you space to air them.

      In the mean time, come back next week for more of my amateur sensationalist claptrap – maybe I’ll use your comments as a reference and apply for a job at The Sun.

      2
      Reply
      • sgncfc says

        15th December 2025 at 3:27 pm

        James

        I’d be interested to know how, as such an amateur, you know so much about the running of the club that you can so categorically state which specific signings were down solely to Knapper and which were not? Your conclusions simply continue with this site’s constant parroting that everything bad = Knapper and everything good = someone else. That’s why it’s dreadful; because it’s so clearly a bit more nuanced than that.

        I have no flame to burn for Ben Knapper, other than the ludicrous vitriol he and his family have been subjected to by people who read and believe this sort of nonsense. Appointing Manning and selling Nunez to them were clearly signs of a man who isn’t quite in synch yet with NCFC supporters, but I expect sites like this, amateur or not, which hold themselves out to be of a reasonable journalistic standard, to be better than this, which is pinkun messageboard stuff.

        If that’s where you’re aligning yourself as an opinion writer, then fine; but I don’t think it’s correct and I’m just expressing that opinion.

        Reply
        • Gary Gowers says

          15th December 2025 at 4:23 pm

          James’ column is – as are most MFW columns (including those that you wrote) – opinion pieces. You’re free to criticise them and express your own opinions (as you have done).

          What isn’t needed is impoliteness.

          We pride this on being a friendly space where differing opinions can be expressed without fear of hostility or venom.

          I aim to keep it that way.

          I’m happy to continue this discussion via email.

          4
          Reply
        • George says

          15th December 2025 at 5:29 pm

          This is all a bit harsh. I think while it’s fair to constructively criticise or even just disagree with something in an article, you’re actually the one that has brought this down to Pink Un messageboard level with the tone of your responses.

          I would also point out that a lot of articles which are of a professional nature (i.e. written by PinkUn staffers – and to a wider extent, even stuff written by national sports journos) are actually opinion pieces based on their own guesses and estimations on things in order to generate the content.

          Perhaps James should’ve stated a bit more clearly that he *believes* these things to be true, rather than stating them. But it’s a bit harsh to judge articles written free of charge, on an amateur level fanzine type site like this, to the same standards as professional journalists.

          Btw James – I thought when you wrote “confession time” – you were about to confess to arson!

          Reply
      • sgncfc says

        15th December 2025 at 4:08 pm

        James

        I did reply in detail to this but your moderators didn’t post it – obviously I’m not allowed to criticise anything,

        Yes, we are both entitled to our opinions and my opinion is that your article is not very good. But if your last sentence is anything to go by in your comment, you shouldn’t be publishing anything on a public forum if you can’t take criticism.

        Let’s see if this gets through…..

        Reply
        • Gary Gowers says

          15th December 2025 at 4:16 pm

          I didn’t post it because I was away from my desk. Simple as that.

          It’s posted now.

          I’m unable to post every comment as it lands I’m afraid. That’s not possible.

          So, yes, you ARE allowed to criticise.

          Reply
        • Gary Gowers says

          15th December 2025 at 4:17 pm

          I repeat…

          I didn’t post it because I was away from my desk. Simple as that.

          It’s posted now.

          I’m unable to post every comment as it lands I’m afraid. That’s not possible.

          So, yes, you ARE allowed to criticise.

          Reply
          • AlexB says

            15th December 2025 at 8:02 pm

            Gary

            Question did in the not so long distance past 3 Ex MFW writers join the Pink-un as in James, Connor and Sam and hasn’t Robin Sainty written articles for this site ?

            Everybody has to start somewhere

          • Gary Gowers says

            15th December 2025 at 9:04 pm

            Yes, yes, and yes 😊

  3. Paul Harley says

    15th December 2025 at 4:43 pm

    It does feel like we’ve got our club back and that Clement has performed miracles, at least compared to most of what went before this season. Let’s wait a bit longer before we say he’s turned it around. The proof will be in comfortably avoiding relegation – early days but I’m optimistic. That too will give perspective on the job Knapper has done (obviously Manning was a poor appointment). Strangely I was most impressed by the fact that Soton didn’t get out of their own half in the 7 or 8 minutes of injury time. I haven’t seen City perform a professional job like that for a long time. OTBC

    4
    Reply
    • James Colman says

      15th December 2025 at 6:32 pm

      I was really impressed with the way they pressed. Even during the halcyon days of Daniel Farke, we didn’t do this.
      There was a stat that for the entirety of the added time we didn’t allow them out of their half – something like that.
      It makes a change – it’s usually teams doing that to us!

      1
      Reply
      • Canarylad says

        16th December 2025 at 1:40 am

        Yea that is more or less a complete turn around from what we have witnessed, more forceful and positive.

        Still early days but the credit points are collecting for Knapper on this one..3rd time lucky …so far

        Reply
  4. Canarylad says

    16th December 2025 at 1:37 am

    As. Regular commentor on here, in fact the only City backed site I do. I could not see much wrong in the article at all. When writers who are classed as professional (Do it for a living employed by media). Saw fit to criticse both recruitment and the management of. By Sporting director. Even ex players of this club, also publicly criticsed the SD, I do not think any fans doing the same can be blamed for doing much the same.

    Several commenters on here, said at times the real fault of poor looking players was down to coaching or lack of it. But who is overall responsible ? The sporting director, this is what he is employed to do.

    The appointment of Manning was very bad judgement, given that Knapper and whoever else was involved, said that much research was given to appointing him. Clearly not the case if his performance is anything to go by. A fact proven by the need to sack, personally I think he was too hasty in sacking JHT and GR but not quick enough in Manning

    These sackings of. The two coaches prior to Manning does open him up to being questioned, as does his seemingly phobia of talking to media and engaging with supporters.

    As to signings, Over the time this club has had a SD, I have been lead to believe they are responsible for all signings Staff and players alike, also to have a major say in the way club plays and operates on the playing level.
    This has not been as successful as it could have been. In fact we have been in perhaps one of the worst eras we have been in since earlier in this century.

    I understand that coaches do have a say in who they would like to have on a transfer, but the overall decisions lay with the SD, hence why we now employ Coaches and not managers

    People in the public eye put themselves open to judgement more than most, especially in such a subjective thing as football.

    There is a way of disagreeing with what has been written, without insult and rudeness. The platform is open, for which we should be grateful, many web sites, hide behind a wall of denying comment.

    I take the line, if I do not like a site as you appear to, I move on, instead of insulting aggressively.
    I try an appreciate the time people put into research and writing by giving respect their views, and using my right of reply given me , to put my view.
    just a few of my thoughts

    6
    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

As featured on NewsNow: Norwich City news” style=

Norwich City News 24/7

@NorwichCityFC Latest

norwichcityfc

Norwich City FC

@norwichcityfc ·
22h

Cool as you like 😮‍💨

3

norwichcityfc

Norwich City FC

@norwichcityfc ·
22h

We will remember them 💛

2

norwichcityfc

Norwich City FC

@norwichcityfc ·
23h

Effective in both boxes 👊

norwichcityfc

Norwich City FC

@norwichcityfc ·
23h

Won it, scored it, love it 🎯

Copyright © 2026 21VC Ltd | All rights reserved | Not to be reproduced without prior permission.

Disclaimer: The information on this website consists of personal opinions. Whilst we have taken all reasonable steps to ensure that the information contained on these Web pages is accurate and correct at the time of writing we do not accept any liability whatsover for any loss or damage caused by reliance on this information.

We do not accept any responsibility for information contained in other websites to which this site links. We strongly advise users to check any information before acting or relying on it.

Developed and Hosted by